Buffykins, the only one throwing little girl tantrums here is YOU. The only one who keeps proving she can't read or keep up, the one who is yet ANOTHER *snore* Nina stan, with zero industry know-how or rational thought processes, is, well, not me!
If you want to take part in high profile message board commentary, pretty please with Splenda, be capable of basic comprehension. How many times do I need to spell out that I made a super specific note about NINANOTPAUL no longer being viable for brand new shows featuring teenagers? How much clearer must I be, to point out that Paul was cast eight *beep* years ago??? He would NEVER be considered for the role TODAY. -that said, unlike Paul and the entire rest of the fanged cast, your girl *very* visably aged. Granted, that's largely on the network for major things like allowing her to destroy and majorly alter her hair, but I digress.
Also, unlike Paul, Nina WAS cast as a
teen and was responsible for not one, but 2 leading characters looking as young and as fit as they did in the finales of season 1 and season 3, respectively. And unlike things like hair, makeup and weight, Nina had no control over at least some of the most notable changes in her facial structure. That was a result of shooting the pilot at 19 and moving into her mid 20's.
I'm still glad it was her who was cast, if you weren't so defensive, you'd see my comments as mere observations and shop-talk. Not hate. Up until around mid season 4, I adored Elena and was generally very impressed with Nina's work. Not to mention from a superficial standpoint, her beauty was captivating. *and before you choke on those bunched panties, I'm NOT calling her unattractive Now.
When Rachel was cast as Allie, she was not a household name and if known at all, it was for playing a HS kid. Not only has Nina said REPEATEDLY that she's DONE with HS (I know how well you guys listen to that sentiment on the NIAN front, so...), girlfriend Is No Longer Viable to start in such a TELEVISION role. If she wants to play younger in a film and casting is already partial to her, then good for her if she comes in and blows away the competition. Especially in comedies and rom-coms, where suspension of disbelief is long and strong, it's perfectly possible. Tho she supposedly left TVD for grittier, more adult and challenging roles.
Personally, I think Nina is the PERFECT TV Allie. But I'm talking Nina circa seasons 1 & 2 of TVD. With her personality, physicality and looks, had she come in and read for it as an unknown back then, she would have likely nailed it in a heartbeat. -and that's another thing: the CW is extremely partial toward unknown, fresh faces for their brand new leads and supporting ensembles. They have look books stretching to the moon with such actors, from Vampire Diaries, TO, The 100, and on and on.
Please stop making this so personal. If you are yourself in HS, then I apologize, as it's understandably what you know. But if that Is the case, there are plenty of forums where you can more comfortably interact with like-minded peers. If you want to be on the IMDB message boards, however, know that you're talking not just to all ages, but to MANY industry professionals and folks with far greater life experience, by default. Have a good nite =}
reply
share