Marry her cousin???


Did people do that during that century???


That is disgusting... even if he wasn't her cousin, he's a disgusting freak anyway.

reply

You're not very familiar with Jane Austen's work, are you? It's a "values dissonance" sort of thing between now and the late 18th/early 19th centuries in which she lived, and it shows up a few times in her novels. Age gaps are treated similarly, as it's something of a plot point in "Sense and Sensibility" where it's perfectly acceptable for grown men (Colonel Brandon, mid-30's and teen girls (Marianne, 17) to get married. In fact, considering her other suitor, Willoughby who is rather closer to her own age.... let's just say it wasn't Brandon who broke her heart.

All in all, yeah, those things are likely to give a case of Squick to modern audiences unfamiliar with her work, but they were truly accepted practices back in those days.

reply

And in Gilbert and Sullivan's light opera HMS Pinafore, which opened in London in 1878, Sir Joseph Porter, First Lord of the Admiralty, marries his cousin Hebe at the end of the opera. Marriage to first cousins was apparently common throughout the Victorian era.

reply

Not just in Austen's work... it was a fact of the time.

reply

Keep in mind that "cousin" could refer to a cousin of any degree, not just a first cousin. The character of Collins in the book is actually a somewhat distant cousin of Mr. Bennet, not any closer related than that.

However, because the Bennet estate was entailed (and had to pass by law to the next male heir in line), it would pass to Collins on Mr. Bennet's demise.

reply

And in most places today, it is still perfectly legal to marry a 2nd cousin

reply

Yes, this was especially true among the upper classes where the marriage pool was smaller (and in this AU the pool would be smaller still) and where they often wanted to keep property in the family. Mr. Collins isn’t the only one, Darcy’s aunt wants him to marry her daughter who is his first cousin, not even a distant cousin like Mr. Collins. In a situation like the Bennet's, where there are all daughters and a cousin is inheriting many people would see it as ideal for one of the daughters to marry the heir.

It may seem disgusting to you but that’s a cultural attitude you’ve been raised with and today we know more about genetics and the effects of intermarriage. At the time it was normal enough that no one would have thought anything about it. I’m sure there are things we do now that would seem disgusting to people from other periods in history or will to those in the future.

reply

Oh boy! You should see my family tree.
The Divine Genealogy Goddess

reply

First cousins marrying isn't genetically awful.

Just so you know, Queen Victoria married her first cousin, Prince Albert. And several of their grandchildren married each other.

http://currentscene.wordpress.com

reply

And that's how the royal family had such genetically-based problems as hemophilia

reply

Thankfully, the younger generations of today's royal families seem to be marrying outside the class pool (and so, the gene pool as well).

reply

Actually, I recently read a book on the royal family's hemophilia. It seems that it could have been a mutation in Victoria herself, because there hadn't been hemophilia in the family before she gave it to her son, Prince Leopold. If she'd gotten it "naturally," then the Duke of Kent wasn't her biological father.

If a daughter isn't a carrier (or doesn't have the mutation) and she marries a man who doesn't have the disease, then they can't pass it on. Cousins or no cousins.

http://currentscene.wordpress.com

reply

According to Whovians, I believe it was Werewolfism...

reply

Common at that time....you must be a youngin.....also in Downton Abby...

reply

People still marry their cousins today, especially in cultures that promote arranged marriage.

A girl in my office married her first cousin from Pakistan, they have the same Grandma.

reply

Thats so weird.


Lose the Game!!!!!!!

reply

Ain't that what the "royalty" does to this day? A bunch of inbred, rich *beep*

reply

Not anymore. Most of the royal houses of Europe have married outside royalty.




http://currentscene.wordpress.com

reply

yes, gross, but their primogeniture laws encouraged it since it would keep the money in the family.

reply