What i never understand...


With any of these movies with zombies or creatures that hunt by sound, i dont get it. How do they know what sounds to attack or react to?? Water rushing, fire crackling, leaves and trees blowing, them themselves moving and attacking are making noise and they dont confuse themselves nor any of the others. To me it sure seem like they'd bumble around confused and attacking about anything.

And you tell me that friendly cat never purrs or meows?

Since they are attracted to sound, you just keep rocks or small hard things in your pocket or bag to throw and distract if they get close or if you accidentally make noise.

reply

You hit on the 2 things I thought about most while watching this movie.

The aliens make a racket themselves when they're following the choppers around, how do they not get distracted by their own sounds?

Yep, I kept on thinking that you'd probably get out of most problems if you just had a pocketful of stones/projectiles, especially in a city environment where literally throwing anywhere metres around you would create a loud enough noise.

Unfortunately the more I see these movies the more I realise they keep throwing up flaws and ways for these aliens to be tricked.

reply

Yeah, i generally put them on for background noise. But i pay enough attention.

Idk why they make these movies with sound being the focal point. Be so much more plausible if they used sonar or heat detecting. Or heat detecting with hearing. Or hearing with a minimal amount of sight.

I put more in my comment to guy below, but some of that pertains to your response too.

reply

I figured that, like most creatures, they learn in time what sounds to go for and what to ignore. And that they know that many sounds often lead to what they're seeking (people / food?). Eg. a car engine or sound of the tyres means a person might be in it.

And yeah... that cat. Having that cat was a massive liability. Why it didn't hiss, meow or purr is so odd.

And also, I was also thinking about how the creatures themselves make all that racket! Smashing things, knocking stuff, breaking glass, etc.

reply

You'd have to assume this world is new to them, so all these sounds would take time to know whats what.

Another thing is with them having the hearing they have, you couldn't breath or have a heart beat. They'd hear that.

Why dont they attack animals? Maybe they do, we just dont see it. Just saying they'd be busy attacking alot of stuff besides humans.

When they arrived on the planet, whats the chances they landed on every continent. So, there should be places without them enough to fight back.

Also, the navies could be on the coast attracting them to waters edge and just wipe them out in masses. I mean, all kinds of ways these things would kill alot, but humans would win out. Love how all these movies our armies become inept and useless

reply

I 100% agree. In fact, this is an issue I have with any "blind monster that hunts by sound" movie.

In real life, there are basically ZERO species of animals that are totally blind and hunt 100% by sound. Even bats have much better vision than you might think. There's that Netflix movie called The Silence that also has monsters that hunt by sound, but their hearing is so fucking sensitive (they can hear a single footstep in the woods from 100 yards away) that they simply couldn't exist.

Sorry, people say "well, they have selective hearing and have learned to filter out footsteps from the sounds of rain or wind" but no, that's impossible. Imfuckingpossible. That would be like if we could filter a rainstorm the sound of a fly farting from two houses down. Even if we were blind and used hearing to 100% navigate through life, it's simply impossible. It's basically telekenesis at that point.

Tremors is the only "blind monster that hunts by sound" movie I've seen that's believable because they hunt specifically by vibration, not sound. So technically they COULD learn the different between the vibrations of a footstep and the vibrations of branches rustling, AND the filmmakers thought about this and show the monsters learning the differences between the two vibrations.

reply

Nice comment. I cant argue with anything there. Other than bats use sonar/echo to navigate, not by just sound itself. but as you stated, they also have vision.

Tremors is a great movie to point out. Good movie to watch, lol

These monsters using sound only in movies is just ridiculous. Bought as bad as zombies like in TWD could actually pose a real threat to society. Now, zombies like from world war Z or I am Legend are at least more believable to have been able to collapse society and over ran human

reply