Which is the best Pirates of the Caribbean film?


I'd say Dead Man's chest! This movie made me love these films and as a result I bought the whole collection last year (plus the lego video game for PS3 :p)! But many people have different opinions! What is yours?

reply

[deleted]

Can't really say, what with not having seen the first three in years, but at the time of watching them I thought something along these lines.

Curse: Good.
Chest. Good.
End: Slow and weird.
Tides: Alright.

reply

i'd have to go with 3. i honestly think geoffrey rush outshone everyone else in the movie. the lack of him in dead man's chest is probably why it's my least favorite of the four, even though it is still quite good.

"Cinema was made for fantasy, rather than normal types of stories." - Ray Harryhausen

reply

I like them all equally.

-----
http://www.youtube.com/dinoatcharterdotnet

reply

Curse of the Black Pearl, to me, came together better than the rest of the films in the series did. I also wasn't a huge fan of the side characters in any of them. I could just barely tolerate Will and Elizabeth, both being hit or miss (more miss than hit too...).

reply

On Stranger Tides I thought because the pacing was better, I thought it was off in all the others and they were kinda slow which I didn't like.

real human being and a real hero

reply

[deleted]

all of them!!! best movie series ever!!!

reply

In order from fave to least fave is;

P.O.T.C - Curse of The Black Pearl
P.O.T.C - Dead Man's Chest AND At Worlds End (They tie in as equally good for me)
P.O.T.C - On Stranger Tides.

Don't get me wrong, I still enjoyed watching the 4th installment, but things just seemed off with it. I felt the first 3 were a complete story, like LOTR. They wrapped it up and that was that. The 4th one felt like an unnecessary but enjoyable add-on of a video game

reply