they sell this to me as a HORROR film, no matter how many excuses of clever twist you wanna throw at this, this is a comedic movie! not a single time in the whole movie was i scared how can i be? everything is extremely telegraphed for laughs and so we can say "ohhh yeah dumb horror movies are like this hahaha so clever" this is in the same league as scary movie, i really think this needs a re-clasification one of the worst movies i've seen, even a bad horror movie (the ones that this mocks) is more honest, they try to scare you with an attempt at horror and fail but this is not that, this is outright comedy
You may not have been scared, and that's fine, but the movie is still a horror movie. Your opinion of it doesn't change the genre. I didn't laugh once at Scary Movie 2, doesn't mean it wasn't a comedy.
Elements are telegraphed not for comedy, but for deconstruction.
The concept was great. And they could've taken this movie to a really terrifying place. Not monsters attacking our heroes, but humans having full control over their situation. That's what it really seemed for a while. If only they'd explore that. Instead they made this stupid satire for horror geeks to get all excited about, how they get all the references and so on.
This movie was an elitist way of looking at horror tropes, made with the finesse of a baboon. They should've gone the full horror route, not the satire one. It's self-applauding, boring and masturbatory.
No. The movie was poking fun at the state of the horror genre and ludicrisy of horror fans who lap up the same thing over and over and over again. If you didn't get it, the "Gods" were the audiences of the horror genre. This movie is perfection.
Jen has it 100% accurate. And the horror geeks don't want to admit they're being made fun of.
I call it an "anti horror" film myself, but still it belongs in many classifications. This is a very deep film, with lots of symbolism, lots of metaphors, lots of what we usually like in "writing". I was impressed.
Even the smallest lines were meaningful. Where the "officer" characters say they're celebrating, the woman among the "enlisted" who is closest to them, denotes the subtle but important difference, that she is "drinking" instead of celebrating. From this excellent line, we see that the enlisted are doing jobs, and not part of the insane ideology, although they do "abet" it, though we get the impression they would rather not.
The bits with the Japanese girls was even more telling, and allusions not only to the "camaraderie" of Battle Royale, but also to the Japanese prison commander of Kwai, who said "better to die like a soldier than live like a coolie". Indeed, all the other cultures decide not to be slaves to horror ahead of the U.S. culture. Talk about a great slap in the face against the horror geeks. Wow!
I thought all the screen writers in the business were hacks, but these two guys made me change my opinion. The fact is they stepped on a lot of toes, but those are toes that needed to be stepped on.
I completely agree. There is nothing worse than a comedy horror movie. If it were a horror movie with amusing situations that would have been a whole different movie. A real disappointment.
Live Full & Die Empty. Tap Your Potential and Realize Your Dreams!
It's not comedy. It's satire. Scary Movie is a comedy spoofing horror movies. This movie was poking fun at horror movies in a satirical way. Big difference. It's sort of like the way The Truman Show poked fun at how people get too engrossed in television. It's not a 'ha ha' comedy. Not supposed to be. Just irony and satire.
Two sides of the same coin. The movie doesn't play like a straight horror movie and that was what was expected, at least by this viewer.
BTW, Happy Halloween!
In response to:
by Rockhound6165 » 2 hours ago (Fri Oct 31 2014 13:25:02) IMDb member since April 2004
It's not comedy. It's satire. Scary Movie is a comedy spoofing horror movies. This movie was poking fun at horror movies in a satirical way. Big difference. It's sort of like the way The Truman Show poked fun at how people get too engrossed in television. It's not a 'ha ha' comedy. Not supposed to be. Just irony and satire.
Live Full & Die Empty. Tap Your Potential and Realize Your Dreams!
I found it really fun and enjoyable while watching it and didn't feel scared at all. But when I went to bed I had weird dreams about the dismemberment goblins and the zombies. Peculiar.....
This movie is great, I am surprised that you are so offended this was not what you expected it to be. Some people just cant get past their bold headed expectations and have to hate what a enjoyable ride it could have been.