MovieChat Forums > What If...? (2021) Discussion > 1st Episode is meh, 2nd one is Brilliant

1st Episode is meh, 2nd one is Brilliant


I'm not much of a cartoon person. Honestly, I'm not a cartoon person at all. I just about never watch cartoons unless it's with my children, so I didn't even realize that "What If...?" was out until quite recently.

I tried to watch the first episode, but lost interest, and kind of zipped through and watched a bit here and there. I didn't bother to watch the end.

I wasn't going to watch the second episode, but I had half an hour to kill this morning, so I thought I'd see if it was any better, and boy was I surprised.

The second episode is everything the first isn't. It's cleverly written, and perfectly paced. The story scoots along, and it was immense fun seeing, or at least hearing, so many MCU favorites again; it was bittersweet hearing Boseman's voice.

The episode was funny at times, and touching at others. Most of all, it was intelligent. We saw what might have been had someone tried to reason with Thanos rather than physically challenge him. Even better, we got to see the Black Order unleashed in a way that we never really did in the films, and against Thanos to boot.

I'll give the third episode a chance based solely on how great the second episode was, despite my general disinterest in all things animated.

reply

You got it backwards. 1st episode is brilliant, 2nd is "meh".

reply

First was fun, not much more.
Second was very nice, but with a truckload of cheese.
Third was pretty fucking bad-ass.

reply

I agree with your assessment regarding all 3 episodes. I really coulda done without that 2nd episode.

reply

Agree 100%. The third episode is also very good, on a similar level to episode 2. The series is a lot more fun than I expected. The writing is great and the familiar characters are used in interesting new ways.

reply

Episode 3 is out? I'll give it a go and report back!

reply