MovieChat Forums > Milk (2009) Discussion > Do they talk about how he was a pedo?

Do they talk about how he was a pedo?


Anyone know

reply

I would bet money they DON'T.

reply

Why would "they"?

reply

To be historically accurate about an historical figure.

reply

I posted the story below. When Milk as 33 he dated an 18-year-old. By no stretch of the imagination is that pedophilia. Pedos have sex with prepubescent children, under 11 or 12 and thereabouts.

Stop slandering the man because you don't like him. If you have evidence he had sex with anyone under the age of consent, let alone a baby, put up or shut up.

reply

He was 18 WHEN THEY TRAVELLED TOGETHER. Their relationship started when the kid was 16.

This pretense that gay men are all nice guys that want relationships that are romantic and similar to what normal people have and blah, blah, blah,

is not real. Hence the NOT TALKING about real shit.


reply

Haha. I know of no such pretense. Most gays are insufferable. Especially the ones you breeders love who get married and ape your pseudo-religious farce.

Gay men, like all men, will take sex over romance anyway.

I'm just saying there's nothing pedophilic about being attracted to a teenager. Most of us have a "look but don't touch" motto.

There is no proof he had sex with the guy when he was 16. Politicians meet a lot of people and have a lot of friends.

So stop slandering the man until you have proof.

reply

It is not credible that you are unaware of such pretense.

That is why the movie didn't mention it, to maintain the illusion of the pretense.

You say you are unaware of it, while DISCUSSING IT.




reply

You're talking about political correctness where all women are stronger and smarter than men, all blacks have more class than whites, and gays don't fuck any chance we get. We all know the drill and nobody buys that crap.

The OP called the man a pedo. You realize pedos don't have sex with teenagers, right? It's just lame. Use correct terminology. I'm not sure why you're defending the OP when he offers not one shred of proof. It's a troll thread, dude.

reply

I don't know how many people really buy it, but they push the shit out of it, they pretend to buy it, and they base policies on it.

AND, they cancel people that don't play along.

So, it's real and it's worth calling out.

reply

But you realize the left now would cancel the fuck outta Milk for even fucking an 18-year-old, right? The left is more sexually prudish than the right now.

Feminists are saying all sex is rape.

You're sorta playing into the left's hands.

reply

Depends if he's useful. Remember the way the feminists rallied around Bill Fucking Clinton, like the good little obedient lefties that they are.

The left wants to pretend that homosexuals are... nice, and good, if not BETTER than hetrosexuals.


When in really, people, especially men, without restraint, are pigs.

reply

When in really, people, especially men, without restraint, are pigs.


Well I think you got to the core of the matter. All men are "pigs" when it comes to sex, not just gay men.

reply

And gay men are not restrained by women's differences. So they are degenerate to levels of behavior beyond the imagination of normal men.

With serious and negative consequences.

Today, we as a society pretend that this is not true. So, we live in a state of willful blindness.

reply

Lol. Since when is having lots of sex degenerate? Are you one of them there those Christians by any chance?

I'd say gay marriage damages society. Leaving us fags alone to fuck whoever we want has no negative impact on you or society.

reply

Since "lots of sex" was the least of the traits I was referring to.

reply

“This pretense that gay men are all nice guys that want relationships that are romantic and similar to what normal people have and blah, blah, blah”

Right, so there are no older heterosexual men that marry 18 year olds? Clearly not a Real Housewives viewer.

What normal straight relationships are those fags aspiring to anyway? Pam and Tommy? Johnny and Amber? OJ and Nicole?? What about Elvis and Priscilla.. a beloved American romance that’s actually more questionable than this bs about Milk.. bet not many are rushing to the ELVIS WAS A PEDO thread with pitchforks like here.

reply

If someone made a movie about... any of those couples you mentioned and left out the negative aspects of their relationships,

it would be completely legit to ask WHY, and WHAT THE GOAL OF THAT WAS.

Do you not agree?

reply

Milk wasn’t a romance movie. Also, he dated an 18 year old when he was in his 30s.. if it was a movie about a straight man who did the same it wouldn’t be relevant to the big picture and I 100% believe you wouldn’t be on the page insinuating he’s an example of heterosexual degeneracy.

So. Thoughts on Elvis?

reply

Milk wasn't a romance movie, correct, it was a glorify and normalize gay men movie.


Elvis? What about him?

reply

Milk was not a pedophile. That was an unhinged allegation from some right wing school board member. When Milk was 33 he dated an 18-year-old. Pedophiles have sex with prepubescent children, not 18-year-old adults.

At a news conference on Wednesday, Komrosky claimed that he was not referring to Milk's sexuality, but rather reports that he had engaged in a relationship with a teenager. As written about in his biography, Milk was involved with a 16-year-old boy he met in New York when he was 33, though it has been documented that the boy was 18 when he and Milk first traveled to California together.

https://www.advocate.com/news/harvey-milk-school-district-pedophile#rebelltitem1

reply

Oh yeah, it just all coincidentally lines up with the stereotype of gay guys grooming and being pedos.

reply

But it doesn't line up. He dated an 18-year-old.

reply

It says it started when the boy was 16. That makes him an ephebophile but not a paedophile.

reply

Exactly. If even that. I asked for proof Milk had sex with him when he was 16. I got none. The story says he traveled with him when he was 18. So sure, close proximity, and they no doubt fucked. But he could have known him beforehand during a campaign or gay rights activity, whatever, but they didn't fuck.

I'm just saying Milk is not a pedo by definition even if the allegations are true. And there's no proof he even had sex with him under 18, just after he turned 18.

Just a bunch of homophobic hysteria and slander methinks.

reply

I've seen the movie. No it doesn't have any scenes involving Harvey Milk doing anything sexually inappropriate with minors. The movie focuses on his rise in politics up to his assassination. I think it was an assassination. It looked like an assassination.

reply

I don't know. But I don't care for this American spelling.

reply