MovieChat Forums > The Wolf of Wall Street (2013) Discussion > Speaks to Scorsese's Catholic Sense of P...

Speaks to Scorsese's Catholic Sense of Punishment -- Just Like GoodFellas and Casino


SPOILERS FOR GOODFELLAS, CASINO, THE DEPARTED AND THE WOLF OF WALL STREET

There were murders in GoodFellas and Casino -- Mafia movies both -- but ultimately Scorsese was quite moral at the end of both movies.

The Mafia men got rich and lived the high life(at nightclubs) and even if married had goomars on the side but -- at the end of both GoodFellas and Casino -- a lot of these characters got executed BY the Mafia(especially in Casino) and put in prison (moreso in Goodfellas.)

There are no murders in The Wolf of Wall Street. The Wolf of Wall Street opens with Leo high on his own greed -- telling us about all his drugs, his mansion, his yacht, his too-hot trophy wife (AND his hookers) and --comes the end of the movie, he loses it all. Nobody on his team gets executed, but Leo goes to jail.

I think all three movies(and throw in The Departed for good measure and what happens to Nicholson, Winstone, and Damon) reflect a sense of justice and punishment in Scorsese's worldview that simply didn't sound as much in The Godfather(where Michael keeps his wealth and dies of natural causes, an old man) or The Sopranos(where whatever really happened to Tony, we were never shown him paying any price for his crimes.)

I don't know enough about Catholocism to know if that's the root of Scorsese's approach to the ending of his movies but its rather refreshing: crime doesn't pay in Scorsese's world.

reply

Scorsese sugar-coated everyone in his movies. The real life people portrayed weren't as animated and glorious as depicted by their fictionalized counterparts.

reply

I think Scorsese romanticizes and glamorizes evil people. Though The Godfather also glamorizes crime, the story of Michael Corlene is a bit different because he grew up never wanting to be a gangster. Perhaps the most consequential line in the saga is "That's my family, Kay. That's not me." Corleone desperately wants to make the family legitimate, but the higher up he goes, the more corruption he finds. He lives in his own kind of prison, and suffers a fate worse than death. He's tragically flawed.

I think The Departed is superior to the original in every respect -- except the ending. In the American version, the bad guy gets gunned down in an act of vengeance. In the Hong Kong original, he must live with the guilt. I have to retroactively give Scorsese some credit, as it turns out the studio wanted at least one of the leads to survive so that they could manufacture sequels.

A critic once said that film cannot help but romanticize almost anything on screen. Explosions, homicide, whatever. It's a difficult balancing act to show the allure, and then, without being didactic, show that these things are, in fact, terrible. People want Oreos and ice cream, not broccoli and brussels sprouts. They love the delicious smell of cooked meat, but do not actually want to know how it's made. We're constantly bargaining. For the vast majority of Wolf's screen time, we see Belfort working toward, or leading, an exciting life. I think the message people take away is "that's awesome, but get rich the right way (mostly), practice a little moderation, and, most importantly, don't get caught."

reply

Yes, the three could be a trilogy.

reply

Scorcese is known in taking true stories and make them a complete parody which is what this movie is

reply

Evidently, this is his biggest hit to date. I suppose you could say the parody (and comedy, and sex, and drugs) made it so.

reply

that dosent make it good. its succesful because its over the top and full of bullshit scenes. i used to like it as so bad its good kind of film. but when i judge it in critical eyes its terrible

reply

Also thought it was bad and overrated. Its shocking to me it made many best of year film lists etc.

reply

Yes, he makes films about sinners.

They live large and ‘reign in hell’ but it all comes crashing down.

The Depated was interesting in that Leo suffered enormously and died early… but his soul was intact and he could form real relationships, whereas Damon enjoyed increasing worldly success and luck but in the end he was an impotent fake who was betrayed and abandoned by everyone before getting his brains blown out.

reply