Name One Movie That Has a #5 Girl Get a Guy Who’s a #10?

Someone already mentioned it but The Mirror Cracked (Streisand/Jeff Bridges)

Personally, I think any movie where Sarah Jessica Parker gets the guy fits and answers your question.

It's trickier if the question is 'Name a movie in which the woman acknowledges she's a 5 and gets a man who's a 10?' That almost happened in Mirror Cracked, but even then we're led to believe that the Streisand character is not as physically unattractive as she believes - it has more to do with her movie mother (Lauren Bacall) constantly, and unflatteringly, comparing her to 'beautiful' daughter Mimi Rogers.

Contemporary:
This Means War
The Last King of Scotland
The Dark Knight Rises (Anne Hathaway & Christian Bale)
Little Darlings
Absence of Malice
Thelma and Louise

Classics:
Summertime
La Strada(?)
Mr. Skeffington
Essex and Elizabeth
Jezebel
(Lot of Joan Crawford movies)
East of Eden
Somebody Up There Likes Me


Note: While some of these movies contain attractive females, I still consider them less attractive than their romantic leads, so include them here.

10 Things I Hate About You
The Loved Ones

...a little fantastic, and fleeting, and out of reach.

Weird Science, but that doesn't technically count since they made her in their bedroom with bras on their heads.

The Dark Knight...Maggie Gyllenhaal *shudders*

[deleted]

Love Story - Ali McGraw was nice-looking but not enough that would make Ryan O'Neal (in his "10" heyday) give up on his rich life.

Fatal Atraction - Michael Douglas was in his "10" heyday and Glenn Close was never more than a "6".

[deleted]