A Big Unknown


I actually read at least the first 2 or 3 books in this series, and to be honest, I disliked Asimov's disjointed story-telling. He obviously started out by writing short stories to sell to sci-fi magazines to earn money, and only later put them all together in these books, and while they are mildly entertaining, it's not much fun to follow because you have a different set of characters in each story. There's no real set of characters to get emotionally invested in, nor do you ever find out what happens to them later, or know what kind of connection they all have, save that the stories take place in the same galaxy, and that the Foundation empire waxed and waned in size, depending on what Asimov wanted it to be. It symbol, as I remember, was a gold sun on a blue background. I also recall that there was one re-occurring character that showed up in several stories; the Mule. He was a mutant human who vaguely resembled a mule, he was sterile, had a high metabolism, and was a super-powerful telepath, powerful enough to manipulate the minds of millions of people at once. He didn't really become a villain until later stories, and then the heroes (whoever they were) had to work really hard to stop him.

I can't imagine how sci-fi channel is gonna interpret this story, though after watching "The Expanse," I don't have high hopes. It was a weird, disconnected set of space stories to start with, and the way tv shows are done nowadays are total crap, so again, I have no idea how it's gonna go, but I fear it won't be told well.

reply

Didn't they make Gaal a black teen in this version?

reply

I loved the books when I was a geeky teen, I loved the scope and ambition of it, the rise and fall of empires all there in just a few hundred pages.
'
But I can't see it making a good TV series, what makes a good TV shows is characters the audience can like, love, or identify with, and that's one thing that Asimov's books definitely didn't have. And which can't be shoehorned in.

reply

Susan Calvin was an interesting character you could spin in to a miniseries. Or perhaps the detectives from Caves of Steel. Or if you wanted a retro buddies story line then Powell and Donovan from the earlier robot stories.
I think Asimov had plenty of decent characters in his short stories and smaller early novels. Not so much in the later 'fat books' phase maybe?

reply

I loved the books when I was a teen. Asimov and Jack Vance were always my two favorite scifi authors.

How are they gonna interpret it? It's quite easy. I'm telling you exactly what they're gonna make. Let's see if I'm wrong. Probably, I won't.

They're gonna take the first stories, before the Mule and the Second Foundation. The ones about the Foundation being a beacon among pseudo-feudal half-savage states. The Foundation will be a woke place, incluuusive and diveeerse, the beaaaacon of civilization. And then you'll the outside states, savage, half civilized, very white, nazi, evil, climate change deniers, racist and probably Trump supporters. Then there will be some random events which can or can not be based in the books, and then you'll have Hari Seldon giving the usual speech, but they won't use the speeches from the books, but some new ones about inclusivity and diversity. And that will be it.

reply