MovieChat Forums > Jack Reacher (2012) Discussion > Rosamund Pike was terrible in this or ju...

Rosamund Pike was terrible in this or just me?


I've never seen a movie with her but I thought her performance in Jack Reacher stood out, and by that i mean it was terrible. Massive overacting on her part, all her reactions looked fake and it seemed like she didn't know whether to play this role for real or comedy (overdramatization of lines).

Anyone with similar impressions?

reply

It's all over this board, man, you're not alone

Fighting a religious war is like fighting over whose imaginary friend is better.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I agree, I first saw her in Doom and wasn't a fan. The way she yelled in the elevator was a little weird too

reply

By far her best performance was in Gone Girl. She did excellent in that. The other movies that she's been in that I've seen, she's never really left a strong impression one way or the other.

reply

She's great in An Education and Gone Girl. I think in Jack Reacher, the problem is her American accent. It's pretty obvious she's faking the accent and it sounded off. I think it affected her performance negatively.

reply

I agree, maybe its just the way she does an American accent but her line delivery was terrible, imo. And over dramatic reactions, with her eyes nearly popping out of her head.

reply

Gone Girl was definitely her best performance.

reply

She was hot in this one though.

reply

Her role was pretty generic. And she gave a decent generic performance.

reply

Her performance just irks the crap out of me. You're not alone. She was great in Gone Girl.

Haters gonna hate

reply

I didn't think the actress was as bad (though she ain't no Kathy Bates) as the character. Everything Reacher picks up on she was completely clueless about. I understand that she wouldn't notice everything that was out of place, but c'mon. Apparently the Pennsylvania Bar requires little more than a pulse.

reply