Why so low? Why did you hate this?

Oh, I don't know... I just watched it again and I don't hate it anymore. I mean, there's a huge body count and it seems generally a bit excessive in that way. Hundreds of people were eye witnesses who will have to be convinced that didn't see what the saw and that just feels a bit off. I tend to favor a world where monsters and the supernatural are remarkable rather than familiar, but that's not any serious criticism. I don't love it, but it's okay.

I didn't hate it, but I didn't think it was very good either. I haven't seen it since it came out in theaters 14 years ago, but I remember the gore and effects being cool, but the story was really bland and kind of slow.

I still vividly remember when the movie came out it got a ton of bad reviews. I was interested in the movie because I love director Joe Johnston and Emily Blunt was hot! But the bad reviews scared me off, more than 10 years later I watched the movie. I'm shocked the movie wasn't bad, I would say it was above average.

Bad cgi, bad music, bad acting, everything is played off like a joke. It’s clear the actors were only here for a paycheck. Although it is watchable, but definitely feels like a B-movie despite the cast. I would give it a 5/10. Only for die-hard werewolf fans. This is more of a movie that friends watch while drinking beer and riffing on it.

I hated John Talbot being a villain. The Villagers hating John Talbot at the beginning was stupid. The villager falling into his own trap he set for the Wolf Man is stupid. The scene where Larry is put on display in front of so many people is dumb and predictable though I find it funny. But then this is coming from someone who saw the original Wolf Man before this came out and therefore thinks it is better.