MovieChat Forums > Kyle XY (2006) Discussion > Am I the Only One Who Hates Kyle?

Am I the Only One Who Hates Kyle?


I really liked this show during the first season when the mystery of Kyle's origins were being unraveled. Then I slowly came to realize that the plot and the supporting cast are what make this show. Kyle is a dull, flat character. He's an unfaltering "do-gooder" who always seems to say the perfect thing, which is unrealistic to the point of being annoying. He's able to accomplish almost everything he sets out to do with ease. No one can get the best of Kyle, and it's boring to watch any conflict on the show because we know how it ends - with Kyle on top. It's boring to watch a Superman with no Kryptonite to balance the scales. It seems that every scene with Kyle in it is intended to make him seem as "dreamy" as possible so that teenage girls will swoon.

I'm on season 3, and I feel like throwing something at my computer monitor every time Kyle opens his mouth. He reminds me of a five year old who's too simple-minded to see the grey in this world.

reply

I must say compared with other shows with male leads... Kyle indeed was not my favorite. I found myself watching the show not for Kyle, but for Jessie. Which is strange, because i'm a guy, making me much easier to root for a male character rather than a female... but Jessie is simply just too good to be true...

reply

Nope I like do-gooders like Kyle and Clark Kent...

reply

"Then I slowly came to realize that the plot and the supporting cast are what make this show."

To this day, Kyle XY has to be one of my most favorite television shows out there. All of the actors really seemed to enjoy what they were doing and the characters they were portraying, and it showed on screen. In my opinion, it was Matt Dallas who made you not only feel for the character of Kyle right off the bat in the first season, but also be filled with curiosity and intrigue as to who exactly this young man was. There are instances where I find myself saying, "well, I could imagine this other person in that role," and this was not one of those times.

Kyle is definitely a "do-gooder", but is far from a flat character. A flat character is one who is by definition two dimensional and very static; their emotions/feelings or traits never really change, and they usually lack depth. Kyle is constantly conflicted throughout the course of the show. One of the more prominent examples of this is his relationship with Jessi, especially in season 2, as Jessi herself is a very complex character. They share so much with regards to their origins, but at the same time their personalities are on two opposite ends of the spectrum. Kyle struggles to find the good inside of Jessi, wary of whether or not he can trust her. He becomes even more conflicted near the end of season 2 when they start to grow closer as a result of the search for their past, and how that plays with Amanda and Kyle's relationship. On one hand, Kyle knows that he has to find out the truth, that Jessi deserves to know as well, and that he needs her help, but he also has to deal with Amanda's feelings about his inability to share what is going on.

Another huge example is actually in the final episode of the series. One of the themes of season 3 is change. This comes in multiple forms, probably the two most important: Kyle and Jessi becoming romantically involved, and Kyle's extremely fragile relationship with Cassidy that is shattered in the finale.

Kyle says that Nicole was right that he was no longer the person she first met. He has changed because of the events and situations in the story throughout the series. Kyle has always tried to rise above and be the best that he can be, but he is human, and we do see a darker, more aggressive side of Kyle in the final minutes when his anger towards Cassidy culminates in their fight. His family is threatened, Jessi, and Amanda by a man who is trying to rip apart his life -- and he uppercuts the hell out of him.

With the revelation that Cassidy is his brother, it would have been interesting to see how Kyle would have dealt with such a situation in the next season. He has always been about protecting his family, but would he do the same for Cassidy?

"He reminds me of a five year old..."
Keep in mind that he was essentially a newborn in season 1 :p

P.S. Sorry for the wall of text D:



reply

"He's an unfaltering "do-gooder" who always seems to say the perfect thing"

---SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER---
"Nicole had been right when she said she didn't recognize the person I've become."
And then the show was cancelled.
---SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER--SPOILER---

reply

i can't stand him too. at first i thought it was cute, when he wasn't talking! but when the show progressed, i couldn't stand him anymore. i don't think he is at all like Clark Kent and i felt they were trying to make him alot like Superman, but even Clark had a downside and flaws.

reply

I think Kyle's "flaw" was his naive view of the world.

reply

I liked him. He could be a little dull at times but he was still cool. But the rest of his family really helped the show too. I liked the supporting cast so much. Well, except Jessi, I found her annoying most of the time, though she got a bit better as time went on.

reply

Yeh I found him the least interesting character. He started off cool and then just became too simple and good. He was never convincing as a genius imo. He was confused by simple expressions but could ace exams. Might just have been poor acting. The Traegar family, particularly the mother Nicole were great.


Anyway was a very entertaining series. Pity it ended.

reply

i found kyle to be annoying at times becuase hes a superman wannabe

reply

[deleted]

I have started watching this series now, and only after Pilot episode I have a feeling of fast pace. It seems more of a comic n feel-good kind of series e.g. Josh's brotherhood, Lori's stupidity n all.

The story should have revolved more around Kyle's struggle to learn human nature. Like, he had no idea about using toilet, eating food, sleep, clothing, general awareness etc. But he learns everything in the pilot episode which was a big turn off for me.

Should I continue watching ??

reply

I wondered what this show was about. I always thought it was a comedic kids show (guy with no belly button, probably alien, and geared at youngsters. After watching the first 7 episodes, I can say I was quite mistaken. I find the plot enjoyable enough for an adult (me). It's a "journey show". Frankly, it would have seemed silly if it did take him a long time to learn things like using forks, etc. Young people learn things quickly. Imagine if you were plopped in a foreign country and didn't know the language, or the culture. I guarantee within a few short hours you will learn the words for toilet, food, eat, sleep, home, phone, water, etc. You immediately begin picking up things that your brain will register are different than what you know. Your first day will be busy mentally, and you will NOT forget the essentials. The first time you learn "restroom" you will remember, especially if you had to "hold it" for a long time looking for one.

I am more interested in Kyle learning social issue, etc. I like how they focus on one thing sometimes, that he is learning. For example, Kyle wasn't sleeping.

I think a show like this is a challenge to keep going, especially as he continues to learn.

What I don't like? The annoying kids. I think the acting was fair to good, not great. And did I say I found the kids annoying? And no matter how much he wanders, NO ONE figures out not to tell Kyle, "Wait here for me." If anything showed it was too slow, it was the other characters not catching on to NOT leaving Kyle alone for long.

reply