MovieChat Forums > Stay (2007) Discussion > So, the big question? *SPOILERS*

So, the big question? *SPOILERS*


Don't read this is you care about her big secret.



So, would you stay with a girl who told you she blew her dog?

My answer: Christ no. Yech. Yeeeeeech. boogidyboogidgy. I get the willies just thinking about it. If the couple in the flick ends up together it can only be because he went down on his cat or something.

reply


Yeah, I find myself strangel aroused that a girl could be so horny that she'd lower herself to such lengths.Whore.

reply

Did she spit or swallow?

reply

If you had ever tasted it then you will know she swallowed ;)

'I see a boundary, I eat a boundary' - Howard Moon

reply

Is there anything worse in today's society that you would forgive your girlfiend for doing?

Paedophilia seems to be deemed 'better'. I was being sarcastic.

Necrophilia? Maybe that's one for the girls to forgive their boyfriends... (Sorry about my closed mindedness, but I can't think of a way for a girl to have sex with a male corpse).

Homosexuality? That's generally accepted and legal now.

Anything else?

When I first heard about this film (three or four days ago), I thought she had full sex with the dog. Would it have been worse if she had gone the all the way?

What if Gene Wilder had done that story straight?



To die is to live, to live is to die

reply

There are female necrophiliacs.

And the poster who pointed out that women having sex with dogs is probably more common than you think is right on the money.

And given some of the human beings women choose to have sex with, a girlfriend of mine telling me she fellated a dog isn't a dealkiller. Unless she's leaving me for the dog.

reply

Unless she's leaving me for the dog.

I hate when that happens. My girl left me for her dog...said he was just soooo much "bigger" than me. Bad part was, he was a miniature poodle!

reply

Yeah, doggie love is a no-go.

http://shareddarkness.com/2007/05/02/bobcat-goldthwait-interview.aspx

But, per above, Bobcat includes a pic of the dog he jokes was his "inspiration" for the movie. Funny...

reply

Ok, go down to the videostore... find Clerks. Watch it. There, you now have an (accidental) way for a woman to commit necophilia.

reply


Yeah, I find myself strangel aroused that a girl could be so horny that she'd lower herself to such lengths.Whore.


This. There are many depraved acts that would turn me on if they included an attractive woman enjoying herself sexually. It's a biological thing because back when we were cavemen the sight of a female having sex meant we had to be ready in case we got out chance.

Heck a hot girl sucking on just about anything (assuming it's not disease-ridden) is bound to get a positive reaction from any straight man.

reply

If it was like in the movie, where she did it once years ago, didn't get turned on, and then never did it again, then sure. People make mistakes. This one is both puke-worthy and also slightly funny.
If she was stil doing it, though, I would be really mad at her for not telling me before I kissed her. Eew, just the thought of it... That one is a definite no-go.

reply

This is, like, the best thread ever.

http://shareddarkness.com/2006/10/20/sleeping-does-lie.aspx

Ever, I say!

reply

My problem is that she didn't just suck him, she actually got so far to have its sperm in her mouth, that was just so much more disgusting. If she just wanted to suck the dogd, okay, people have different urges at different times, but the sperm? There was no need for that. It was supposed to be a light comedy with family and romance moments in it, yet somehow it was just weird throughout. Overall, a 2/10.

reply

So she should have gotten the dog aroused and then just left him hanging.

reply

Now that would have been cruel. At least letting him finish gives him some relief.

reply

I am stunned by how closeminded people make a huge deal out of something as trivial as this. Sexual exploration that does not lead to harm, and everyone starts screaming their heads off.

Only in the US .... *sigh*

reply

Yes, I would.

If she told me that she *still* does it, and does it regularly, I might question it. But an impulsive act of adolescent sexual curiosity that harmed no one?

No problem with it.

reply

Cracks me up, though, that Mr. High and Mighty Boyfriend actually thinks that jerking off in front of his guy friends and then eating a cookie soaked with their sperm is just a bit of harmless fun and not repulsive at all. Um, OK, dude... whatever helps you to look yourself in the eye.

But then, disgusted though he claims to be by her past indiscretion, he asks her to do it again, in front of him, because it's obvious he's actually turned on by the idea. Then he insults her because she WON'T do it, calling her a dog-blowing (or sucking, can't remember) *c-word* OK, you shallow moron... make up your mind. First it's bad that she did it. Then it's so good you want to watch her do it. Then when she WON'T do it, it's bad again. Typical.

Some things you really don't need to know about your partner's past, unless it involves someone both of you know and regularly associate with (if you slept with my sister--or brother, all the same to me--I wanna know), affects your everyday life (if you're a woman in a man's body, I wanna know) OR it's something that could endanger your life/health. Those things should be revealed and dealt with like adults. Stuff like this... not necessary.

reply

I don't quite understand all the reaction to this "secret".
(1) I was stationed at Fort Bliss in the early 1960's and quite often we would cross the border into ciudad Juarez for the sex shows, many of which involved sex between human females and horses, dogs and donkeys. Maybe even more species. The sex consisted of both oral and regular.
(2) The first sexual experience for many rural boys involved a sheep and a set of waders. Or a chicken.
(3) If you remember the quite popular mainstream movie "Clerks II", I know that you will remember the surprise event that Randal arranged for Dante as his going away present.

reply

Interspecies Erotica! :P

reply

I wouldn't care, really. Most people have done a few things in their teenage years that they're probably not too proud of, it doesn't define them as a person.

reply


So, would you stay with a girl who told you she blew her dog?

My answer: Christ no. Yech. Yeeeeeech. boogidyboogidgy. I get the willies just thinking about it. If the couple in the flick ends up together it can only be because he went down on his cat or something.


Well, would you stay with a guy who preformed cunnilingus on his cat

reply