Top 5 Best Episodes

Bums: Making A Mess (Do I have to jam you up?)
Frank's Pretty Woman (Can I offer you an egg in this trying time?)
The Nightman Cometh (Are you hard right now?)
Sweet Dee Has a Heart Attack (Pepe Sylvia scene is IMO the best scene ever)
Frank Reynolds’ Little Beauties (Do not diddle kids...It's no good diddling kids)

Honorable mentions:
- The Gang Dances Their Asses Off (Cream always rises to the top and you're about to see the white-hot cream of an 8th-grade boy.)
The Gang Hits the Slopes (You will be clean)
The Gang Gets Held Hostage (We're taking you bitches hostage.)
The Gang Gets Stranded in the Woods (Split me open like a coconut)
The Gang Gives Frank an Intervention (I'm gonna get real weird with it)
Frank’s Back in Business (My favorite Dennis episode)
The Gang Gets Invincible (Greenman! McPoyles! Frank on acid in an oil drum!)

No way I can Limit it to Five:
Great episodes that have not been mentioned yet.
- The Gang Gets Whacked Parts 1 & 2
- Mac and Charlie Dies Parts 1 & 2
- The World Series Defense
- Who Got Dee Pregnant
- Charlie Kelly: King of the Rats
- The High School Reunion Parts 1 & 2
- The Gang Dines Out
- Reynolds vs. Reynolds: The Cereal Defense
- Mac and Dennis Buy a Time Share
- Mac Day
- The Gangs Saves the Day
- McPoyle vs. Ponderosa: Trial of the Century
- The Gang Goes to a Water Park
- Hero or Hate Crime?
- A Cricket's Tale
- Time's Up for the Gang

For me my favorites are

The Gang Gets Trapped
The D.E.N.N.I.S. System
Mac and Charlie Die Part 1 & 2
Paddy's Pub: Home of the Original Kitten Mittens
Mac & Dennis Move to the Suburbs
The Gang Hits the Road

I started doing a list but just cannot cut down to 5, I would have a list of around 20 episodes which are 10/10 ratings, and I am sure many Always Sunny lovers feel the same

what are the Rules