MovieChat Forums > El cantante (2007) Discussion > So its official? Salsa is Puerto Rican? ...

So its official? Salsa is Puerto Rican? SPOILERS***


The origins of Salsa has been disputed for years. Some saying its Cuban others insisting its Puerto Rican.

In the movie we see Willie Colon, Hector Lavoe and ( I believe it was) Johnny Pacheco getting together to talk about their careers.

Pacheco says that they will combine different latin genres and make a new rythm called Salsa, or sauce. He said that Willie and Hector are the best to do it for one represents New York and the other Puerto Rico.

Lavoe is from Puerto Rico and the other two are Newyoricans (Puerto Ricans born and/or raised in New York).

Has this movie cleared, once and for all, that Salsa is a Puerto Rican creation?

reply

Johnny Pacheco is a full blooded DOMINICAN NOT Puerto Rican.

reply

Johnny Pacheco is a full blooded DOMINICAN NOT Puerto Rican.

reply

Yes. Johnny Pachecho is indeed Dominican, not to sound stupid, but if you listen to Celia Cruz' song titled "El Guaba" she mentions that Pachecho is from the Dominican Republic.

As far as Salsa music dying, well basically Reggaeton killed it. But not to worry because Reggaeton has dug themselves a grave already with what people call nowadays "tiraera" which in English means to talk bad about each other, just like underground hip hop used to do, but Reggaeton is doing it backwards, meaning hip hop started underground and went on to rap about money, cars, women, clubbing, etc.. whereas Reggaeton used to rap about the clubbin, money thing and then went on to the "tiraera".

This movie depicts Hector as a drug addict, yes, he was, but this movie actually failed to humanize him a little and all the recognitions that Hector received throughout his career.

reply

Salsa is neither Puerto Rican or Cuban. It was created in NYC by Puerto Ricans, West Africans, Cubans, Jews and lots of other people. It's sauce baby a mix of everything, just like NYC.

reply

<<<As far as Salsa music dying, well basically Reggaeton killed it. But not to worry because Reggaeton has dug themselves a grave already with what people call nowadays "tiraera" which in English means to talk bad about each other..>>>

Reggaeton is not declining because of the "tiraera", which has always been a part of the genre from its start and was never hurt by it. Reggaeton is going through the same problems Salsa and even merengue went through. Its simply becoming too commercialized and the wanna be romantics are taking over. All these genres were at their strongest when the rhythms were lively, strong, and the songs involved a variety of topics. These days its hard to find a single salsa, merengue, or even reggaeton song that its not about the same tired theme of losing a girl and wanting her back. It just flat out gets tiring after a while.

reply

[deleted]

Yes, Salsa is Puerto Rican, just as Reggaeton is as well.

reply

Technically, no! Johnny Pacheco is Dominican.

The most beautiful thing ever made:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZVUk-BRZVAM

reply