MovieChat Forums > Casanova (2005) Discussion > Heath Ledger... or David Tennant??

Heath Ledger... or David Tennant??


both played Casanova.
both are pretty darn attractive!!

But which one is better? for me, its Heath Ledger, sorry. He is [/WAS] HOTTTT and totally suited the role..sexy in every way! Sexy voice...
David Tennant is LOVELY too, but just doesnt QUITE do it.
What about you?? Who's your fav Casanova?

xxx






PS.
RIP HEATH x

reply

[deleted]

Tennant played the guy you read in Casanova's memoirs...perfect.

reply

david. you can also see why RTD cast him as the Doctor, plus that smile makes me melt. I loved this so much I bought it.

Coward. Any day.

reply

I havent seen Heath as Casanova but he is hot.

Though David was funny and had such charisma, I watch doctor who just for him :)

Last three movies seen:

Micheal Clayland 1/10
Disterbia 9/10
Saving Private Ryan 3/10

reply

I agree Beautiful Heretic.

reply

i'd go with David Tennant anyday. cheeky smile and absolutley flippin gorgeous. ne1 who wantz 2 argue dat feel free cuz i'll win LOL

reply

Its tough, as I love David. Bu tI think they portrayed Casanova in different ways. They are both funny and witty and a joy to watch.
I watched DTs Casanova over the weekend, and I still loved it.

http://z15.invisionfree.com/David_Tennant_Forum/index.php?act=idx

reply

david. I liked heath's version, but I still have to side with the tennant one.

Today's really gonna suck... BUT AT LEAST I DON'T HAVE SMALLPOX!

reply

Tennant Tennant Tennant

"Well behaved women rarely make history" Laurel Thatcher Ulrich

reply

David Tennant. Always.

Heath Ledger will be a kick ass Joker, though. He'll be missed.

reply

Both!

Sorry, I'm selfish :D

reply

Tennant, by a million miles.
I just couldn't enjoy Ledger's Casanova because I'd seen the David Tennant one first. They weren't even in the same league.

Give your immortality to me; I'll set you up against the stars.

reply

Heath Ledger. i like david tennant too,he was a good Casanova! but heath ledger is something else.he's one of my favorite actors.

RIP HEATH LEDGER!

reply

I haven't seen the Ledger version so can't on him, but to me is misses the point of Casanova slightly to cast a really conventionally good-looking guy in the role. Casanova has had to develop his technique; he's had to become a seducer, charming. Good looking guys never have to try that hard...

reply

Tennant. Nothing against Ledger, but Tennant was AMAZING in the roll.

reply

David, all the way. I love him and i love his version or Casanova, so cute!!!

reply

[deleted]

i love both David Tennant and Heath Ledger as actors and thought that they were both great in their respective Casanova.
I think that i would have to go with David, just because of the scenes where he pretends to be a spy, gives the vicar/priest (or whoever) a heart attack and the fake penis. I also loved Peter O'Toole and Charlie Cox.

reply

I have to say I prefer David Tennant, because he gave the character a whole other dimension- I found Heath Ledger's version a bit blah in comparison.

reply

My vote is for Tennant! I have to say that I thought Heath Ledger's version was a little silly and now that I've seen the Tennant version there's just no comparison. I'm really glad went to such great lengths to find this version (I couldn't get it anywhere! Finally found it on blockbuster.com and rented it through the mail).

reply

Tennant all the way! He's hot, funny, and well, I haven't seen the other ones, but it's on my to do list! :D

----
RocKs huRt Throw More pIes.

reply

I love both! It's near impossible to choose, but I think David just about impressed me a little more.

An idea is only relevant if it's being thought apon.

reply