MovieChat Forums > Grey's Anatomy (2005) Discussion > Something wrong with me 'cause episode b...

Something wrong with me 'cause episode broke my heart?

posted 8 years ago by hughjman
31 replies | jump to latest

Seeing Alex being led out of the hospital like that broke my heart. All those years of work overcoming his childhood abuse. And he thought Deluca was raping Jo, he didn't just hit him for no reason unless I missed something.

Also, Maggie really got on my nerves for the first time, I think. Not only does Meredith have to baby her and give up someone she has mutual feelings for, but Maggie's playing the sister card when they've only known each other for about a year, whereas Meredith and Alex have been friends for years, and great friendship can be as important as siblinghood.

I do think it's tragic if Deluca can't be a surgeon because of his eye injury, but I'm really hoping he will heal. And (as one of the seemingly few people who like Jo) I think she better tell Alex about her abusive marriage in the next episode.

[–] kaasein 8 years ago

I agree with every point you made. I don't try to justify what Alex did, but that scene of him being led out still broke my heart.

Maggie was so unreasonable. I mean she acted like he doesn't know that Alex is Mer's best friend and it must have been an extremely hard night for Mer. She did the right thing in the end, but I think it's understandable that she needed some time.

I loved the episode. I don't get it why so many fans are so harsh on the characters. It's all very dramatic and I think it's important to see from few POVs while watching a show like this.

And I'm so glad that Japril baby is not named after anyone! They really pushed it with baby Bailey and Ellis.

[–] fschiff 8 years ago

Maggie was incredibly selfish.
Annoying bitch.

You're perverted, twisted, and sick. I like that in a person.

[–] Fantomauve 8 years ago

I was actually happy & smiling when I watched that scene. I felt bad, even mortified, for Meredith and their co-workers, but about Karev himself, I was happy. He brought this on himself.