MovieChat Forums > The Departed (2006) Discussion > Hard to see Nicholson in this and in "Fi...

Hard to see Nicholson in this and in "Five Easy Pieces" as the same person


I mean they just don't look the same, by a lot. Some people age and, except for a few wrinkles. look the way they did when young, and some change so much they're almost unrecognizable. Al Pacino is another in the latter category.

Anyway, as many know, this is a remake of a Chinese film called Infernal Affairs, some would say a ripoff of it. IMO, the Chinese film is better, especially in its lack of wall-to-wall music, a Scorsese trademark.

reply

Answer: The Chinese movie - Infernal Affairs - is so superior that it is a real challenge to watch The Departed in comparison. I watched Infernal Affairs within the last few months again just to see if I was mistaken - and I wasn’t - it is just so good. I am glad Scorsese got recognition for his excellent movies, but why for this one?

Nicholson is always good but he is always Nicholson the personality first in any role.

reply