MovieChat Forums > One Tree Hill (2003) Discussion > Brooke, Haley or Peyton

Brooke, Haley or Peyton

posted 9 years ago by DisneyLove1225
24 replies | jump to latest

Who was your main favourite lady?

Brooke was my favourite
Haley second
Peyton last

[–] 9 years ago

[deleted]

[–] Jones_RA 9 years ago

I think Haley had the kindest heart, was the one I related to the most personally, and is probably the only one i would be friends with in real life (in the high school years anyway). But Brooke was the funniest by far and the most interesting to watch.

[–] MsLadybird99 9 years ago

Haley

[–] gbediako 9 years ago

Brooke

[–] NorthernGooner 9 years ago

Peyton by far.
I couldn't choose second out of Haley and Brooke changed between them depending on storylines.

[–] amazingm08 9 years ago

Haley mostly because she stayed consistent out of all the cast

[–] Saintdaniel 9 years ago

I always liked Haley more just because I see a lot of Lucas and Haley's friendship in 1 of my own friendships. Then id say Brooke then Peyton and that's only because when Peyton left Brooke had more time to develop as a character

[–] amazingm08 9 years ago

I just like Haley because she was the least jarring character and remained the same throughout the series though I did have a problem with her tattooing 23 when dating Nathan when it seemed that she was still unsure of him and track record

[–] laxxx028 8 years ago

I think Peyton is my favorite? I just feel I can relate to her the best. Brooke is a very close second though!

[–] elizabethvrock-58532 8 years ago

Brooke! Peyton is a bitch

[–] Louis_de_Pointe_du_Lac 8 years ago

Brooke
Haley
Alex

The only times I ever liked Peyton was the first half of season 1 and when she was with Jake.

You pale to Fox Mulder!
IM COOK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[–] mrsgolightly-39055 8 years ago

Agreed.

[–] LOTRinger02 8 years ago

Brooke and Hayley I never had a problem with. Sure they had moments where you wanted to slap them but they were teenagers, so what would one expect?

Peyton I never liked, not the actress or the character. I didn't like Hilary Burton when she used to be a VG on TRL, and Peyton was emo, hypocritical, super judgemental, and a b*tch. She should have left with Jake. I don't understand why why writers tried so hard in the early seasons to make her the main female character.

~~~~~
Vigorli~Harmony~Thorki~Stucky I SHIP IT!