MovieChat Forums > Harold & Kumar Go to White Castle (2004) Discussion > What kind of name is a kumar patel !!

What kind of name is a kumar patel !!


I am really shocked how hollywood tends to goof up indian names ! Kumar Patel are both last names ! how can a person be called kumar patel ! Same with the heros guy mohinder suresh....both first names ! and mohinder is a punjabi name and the guy in heros is south indian ! I think the script writers must get the names approved from some indian person

reply

I knew a guy named Kumar.

~ On the internet ...no-one can hear you scream

reply

Ever hear of the last name Bradley? I know a Kumar and have heard of several real Kumars.



"There are two kinds of people in this world: Michael Jackson fans and losers."

reply

I knew two Kumars in the high schools I went to- at one it was his first name and the other, Kumar was his last name.

reply

[deleted]

I am Indian and hereby I approve that the first name kumar exists and that you are banned from posting on internet,lol.
I have a friend named kumar Anand and he was the strongest guy in our college.Do you have a problem with that too?

reply

Tell me more of Kumar Anand and his feats of strength.

reply

i know this is an old post, but it made me laugh a lot

reply

same

They speak English in What?

reply

U are obviously gay or closet gay my friend...

reply

Yeah sure, Kerpal. You should know...

No, I don't care what you think. Really. Don't bother replying.

reply

i know this is an old post but still..
maybe his name was actually anad kumar but his official id spelled it surname first(which is usually the case in offcial documents in india)

and for everyone bashing the OP kumar patel is a very odd name

kumar is a family name across north and cental india

kumar is used in south india as prefix or suffix in a name( kumar means boy and kumari means girl)

and mohinder suresh (Heroes) is just absurd

reply

Kumar Anand means blissfull litle boy, doesnt it?
I would also be blissfull, if I was the strongest guy in school...

reply

So Kalpen Modi isn't indian? Are you retarded?

reply

No u moron...kalpen modi is NOT AN INDIAN ...he is an AMERICAN ! to be an indian u have to LIVE IN INDIA... not be ethinically from india...Kalpen modi is ethnically indian but he is an american...

reply

No actually you are wrong its not about where you live, its about where you were born, so if you were born in India but now live in the USA you are considered to be Indian, but if you were born in the USA then yes you are considered American like you said even if both your parents are Indian and were born in India. My father was Greek he was born in Greece and emigrated to Australia when he was 5, therefore he was not Australian but Greek. So try not to call people morons in future when you yourself have no clue.

reply

hello??? Ever heard of Kumar Sangakarra, the Sri Lankan batsman and wicket keeper? you obviously don't know anything. I'm Sri Lankan (many similar names) Australian and to me Mohinder sounds very much like a first name.

reply

Give the guy a break. The movie's so awesome that it doesn't really matter, but the name Kumar Patel IS the first of it's kind. I don't give a *beep* but just for those who're calling this guy wrong, Kumar and Anand are used as first names, YES, but when this is done, the surname is not a commonly used surname. It's like a proper name with the surname and first name reversed.

But then, name is only a reference to a guy, why make a big deal out of it ?

reply

I actually went to school with a Kumar Patel, so it certainly isn't "the first of its kind", nor is it somehow unnatural or ridiculous for the writers to have given him that name in the movie.

As for why people are giving the original poster a hard time, it's sort of a given that when someone makes absolutist statements in an outraged fashion without actually bothering to do a little research, they're almost begging other people who know better to come along and knock them down a few pegs. Had he presented his objections in a more rational, less emotional manner, he probably wouldn't be taking as much flack for it.


reply

U are right...u are PARANOID AND OBSESSIVE...

reply

All of u are idiots !!

U obviously dont know anything
1. Kumar sangakarra is sri lankan....for ur kind info sri lanka is different from india
2. there is and cannot be any person in the world called kumar patel...this kind of bulls**t name cannot exist
3. yes there are guys with first name kumar ...there are guys with stupid first names like skip and trip also ...

reply

@ OmLakhani

Although the name 'Kumar Patel' might be unique to a handful of individuals on the planet, it's a bit far fetched to say that a particular name 'cannot exist' and there 'cannot be any person in the world called' so and so. The world's a big place.

reply

Especially when, if the only thing that makes it unusual is the fact that first and last name come from different cultures, then my own real-life name is apparently impossible (in spite of my actually, you know, having it), since I have a German-derived first name and a Scottish family name. Oh, and an Italian middle name.

For that matter, I actually used to know someone of Sri Lankan descent whose first name was Naomi, which is Hebrew. Clearly, she doesn't actually exist, however, since it apparently utterly impossible for anyone to ever have a name that comes from more than one culture.

reply

It appears you are quite an idiot-i know a Kumar Patel is a a very possible name and so are many other permutations and combinations-Indians have some of the wackiest names. Live with it.The nerve to call us idiots..

reply

3. yes there are guys with first name kumar ...there are guys with stupid first names like skip and trip also ...
If Kumar is such a stupid first name then I would imagine that multi-billionaire Kumar Birla would change it. After all he can afford it.

reply

[deleted]

I know a girl named Pinky Patel. It isn't relivent but I thought I'd just put that out there.

The short one's gawking at me and the tall one's being very droll.

reply