SECRET WINDOW OR GODSEND?

It's a tie, unless you haven't seen Fight Club. In that case, see Secret Window. Anyone who tells you differently only has a hard-on for Depp or DeNiro. They are both huge let downs. Godsend is much scarier in a creepy sort of way though. You'll like Godsend if you aren't one of those fools without a life that gets really caught up in the ethics/morality/feasibility issues. The theatrical ending kills it though and brings it down to the level of Secret Window. As for Secret Window, if you've seen Fight Club you will figure this movie out about halfway through. Godsend might copy some things from Omen or whatever, but Secret Window rips off it's plot twist from Fight Club and is a big let down after you figure this out about 30-45 mins into the movie.

Neither, unfortunately.

THE EXORCIST, in my opinion, is the best out of *any* horror movie ever made.

Kat

Secret window. I haven't been disappointed in a Johnny Depp movie yet (although I think a couple were a little slow but still good: 9th Gate and Sleepy Hollow). I was surprised to find out who Shooter was (maybe I am just dense). Godsend, on the other hand, right from the beginning I was suspicious of the Dr doing something with the DNA, so I was *not* shocked to find that out. I think they could have done more with it, and was almost hoping that it was the old Adam coming back and not the Drs kid. I was expecting way more and was sadly disappointed.

Alot of people said Secret Window was bad but I really enjoyed it I also enjoyed the novella. However there was no book for Godsend so I shouldn't of been able to have figured out the ending 30 minutes. Godsend was a true abomination to film with an ugly child as a huge plot point. Sorry I rule in favor of Secret Window.

Buffy- I'm not exactly shaking in my affordable yet stylish boots-

Secret Window *may* be a better film, but if I had to choose which of the two to watch I would definetly go w/ Godsend.

It wasn't a great movie, but I could not stand to sit through the SW crap again. Atleast this film had a few jumps. SW just went on, and on, and on. Not to mention the twist in Godsend was a bit more to sink your teeth into. The twist in SW was unimaginative, like an exscape route if you can't find a more creative way of explaining whats going on.

Get Paid to watch Movie Trailers - http://www.mb01.com/lnk.asp?o=27&c=199&a=2222

if u wanna see a good movie, rent The Crow. it's my favorite, but only the first one, the sequels sucked. i didn't like godsend, secret window was ok but none of them were outstanding or anything. it's like asking "what
s better: barney or teletubbies?" everyone has their opinions, but in the end, would u really want to watch either of them?i doubt it unless you're under 6 years old

I LIKE SECRET WINDOW MUCH MUCH MUCH MORE THAN GODSENT. IT WAS A BETTER MOVIE WITH A BETTER ACTOR. I ALSO THINK JOHNNY DEPP IS SOOOO HOT!!!!!!!!!!

Definetly Godsend. Secret Window was a disappointment. The multiple personality thing has been overdone completely, so it wasn't even that original. The story's good, but as a movie? Could have been alot better.