SECRET WINDOW OR GODSEND? - Godsend (2004) Discussion

[–] endr377 21 years ago

Secret Window. By a long shot.

reply

[–] 21 years ago

[deleted]

[–] Foggy6 21 years ago

First, I haven't seen any of the alternate endings for Godsend. Having said that, Secret Window was definitely better. It had a solid ending. Godsend... what the h*ll happened? All I could get out of it was that either the first Adam or Zachary pulled him into the closet. With not knowing which one it was, it makes it seem like the 2 personalities are still struggling for control. What kind of an ending is that? I wasn't satisfied at all. Nothing was set in concrete. The audience didn't learn anything new from the ending that they didn't know from the rest of the movie. It made it pointless. Secret Window, however, lived up to the rest of the movie. Shooter wanted a good ending, and that is just what he got. Depp's line about the ending being the most important part would fit right in here in my speech, but I am stupid and cannot remember it.

reply

[–] 21 years ago

[deleted]

[–] spikykyle 21 years ago

I was really disapointed in both. Neither, go re-rent private parts.

reply

[–] shartmann 21 years ago

I hope Secret Window is better because Godsend is BAD BAD BAD

reply

[–] 21 years ago

[deleted]

[–] MEDIAMONGOL 21 years ago

Given that Secret Window was the worst movie I EVER saw, Godsend.

reply

[–] Kakihara-Ichi 21 years ago

in that case secret window must be one of the worst ever horror films ever made

reply

[–] MEDIAMONGOL 21 years ago

Most likely. I'm usually picking about what horror movies I watch though. I don't watch any B-Rates. Only A-Rates.

reply

[–] badmann 21 years ago

You didnt see too many horrors then?

reply

[–] 21 years ago

[deleted]

[–] dirty_lollipops 18 years ago

Given that Secret Window was the worst movie I EVER saw, Godsend.

and why is that? just curious.. :)

reply

[–] sportsfan3527 20 years ago

you r comparing "secret window" to "godsend"? seriously? "secret window" was good, "godsend" sucked sucked sucked

reply

[–] MadameCassel 21 years ago

Godsend, by far. Secret Window was quite dull. I didn't like Rebecca R-S, she is not quite an "actress" and the movie could have been better if someone else did her role, but I liked the plot and as a mother of a son of the same age as Adam I was scared stiff. Terrifying stuff.

Action is the enemy of thought

reply

[–] Vassago 21 years ago

Both are dreadful, of course, but "Godsend" is slightly worse.

reply

[–] eliasabraham15 21 years ago

Secret Window!!!!!! Johnny Depp is great! But Godsend wasn´t that bad, too.

reply

[–] 21 years ago

[deleted]

[–] 21 years ago

[deleted]

[–] GrOoDmAn 21 years ago

Secret Window, by far.

reply

[–] YouGotSlayed 21 years ago

I thought Godsend sucked but it was creepy. one question i have is why do you all hate secret window? I personaly loved the film. I gave it 8.5/10 . Can you tell me spacificly what about it you didn't like.
Thanks

reply

[–] WISHheLUVDme 21 years ago

I didnt think tha Secret Window was that good. I like Godsend a lot better. Secret Window was just violent, and Godsend, there was a small twist and there were parts that madeyou jump. I liked Godsend better, I dont know why everyone hates it?

reply

[–] lil_cupcake 21 years ago

I didn't like either but if I had to choose..probably "Secret Window".

reply

[–] NoahBody 16 years ago

WISHheLUVDme
I didnt think tha Secret Window was that good. I like Godsend a lot better. Secret Window was just violent, and Godsend, there was a small twist and there were parts that madeyou jump. I liked Godsend better, I dont know why everyone hates it?

Someone yelling 'Boo!' makes them a great director?

reply