I'm sorry, but I just saw this again and Hackman stole the show. Anyone else agree? Sometimes the antagonist makes the movie and I think that's the case here.
I just saw it last night for the first time and thought Hackman did an incredible job. Having never seen the movie before, I came away feeling mad at myself for having waited 8 years to watch it.
Another agree - with acknowledgment to Dustin Hoffman as well. Through amazing luck I've had a chance to meet both of these great actors (several years apart) and I loved this pairing in the cast. Gene Hackman does steal the show.
Hackman and Hoffman are both great... but I have always been a bit biased towards the former, perhaps because I have seen more films of his than Hoffman's. I, however, feel that Hackman has a greater range as a performer (and I know that many would disagree)... films like The Conversation, Scarecrow, French Connection, Unforgiven, Night Moves, Mississippi Burning, etc. further testify it.
Hackman is a %^)*^&$0 legend! He scarfed the *beep* out of his co-stars with his reputation; talent and presence. He was one of the truly great America actors. And he was at the top of his game when he called it a day.
Hackman blew everybody's doors off, but I think Hoffman was a serious miscast. I think he was trapped in what I call the "John Wayne Syndrome." You see John Wayne in a movie, and you never think of him in terms of being a character, you see him as John Wayne, first, last, and always. He even wore the same costume in most of his movies.
Harrison Ford is a lot like that. But Dustin Hoffman, to me, couldn't sell me the idea that he could be a principle-driven attorney (how's that for an oxymoron?). He was Dustin Hoffman reading a part. Hackman totally sold me that he was a sleazeball jury-manipulator, and that scene in the bathroom was his and his alone.
Hoffman, give credit, completely had me sold on Dorothy Michaels in Tootsie, one of the best performances of all time by any actor, but not here.
Hoffman wanted the Hackman role, but Hackman was already cast.
Just about any villain role gives an actor a chance to shine, and Hackman's role was far juicier than Hoffman's. Naturally his performance outshone Hoffman's. Both are among the best actors America has ever had.