A moving spiritual experience
This isn't some trite Disney flick with a kid winning at a competition against all odds; it's an independent film with none of the trappings of modern blockbusters. The story is dialogue-driven, slow and not all that eventful, which can of course throw off those used to a steady diet of the latter. Take note before watching.
It turned out to be a veritable religious experience for me. I was captivated from beginning to end (just over an hour and a half without credits). I was in a spiritually-sensitive mode at the time and literally cried. The movie actually spoke to me in a sense and I received clear direction in one area of searching/need. Don't dismiss this on the grounds that I'm some sentimental whack job; I'm just a regular dude.
The thematic clash of the film is not granddaughter against grandfather but rather truth vs. traditionalism, spirit of the law vs. letter of the law, and true calling vs. stubborn opposition.
There's also an interesting sub-theme about a culture losing its identity and languishing in drugs/alcohol, crime and meaningless despondency. How can they, as individuals and as a people, escape this? They must know their identity -- who they ARE.
Some have criticized the film as too predictable, but I'd rather watch "Whale Rider" and it's predictable play-it-straight plot than moronic 'twist' films like "A Perfect Getaway" (2009) where the story is essentially a lie, leaving the viewer feeling hoodwinked and ripped-off. "Whale Rider" is refreshingly honest by comparison. Besides, 'twist' plots have become so common that playing it straight is now 'cutting edge.'
If what I've said piques your interest don't miss out on "Whale Rider." Just wait for the right moment when you know you'll be receptive to such a reverent piece. It will likely move you and maybe even speak to you. Keisha Castle-Hughes, who plays Pai, is precious.
It was shot on the North Island of New Zealand (Whangara, Gisborne & Taupo, Waikato), directed/written by Niki Caro from Witi Ihimaera's book.