MovieChat Forums > Swimfan (2002) Discussion > Whos hotter Madison or Amy

Whos hotter Madison or Amy

posted 21 years ago by blithing2
92 replies | jump to latest

I say Amy shes well nice

[–] ajhdettmer 12 years ago

Both women are pretty. No question about that.
Personaly i have the feeling Amy is more pleasant
to be with and to have around in the long term.

[–] pauldholloway 12 years ago

Shiri Appleby/Amy I would date over Erica for she seems more my type of girl next door type women. Both are hot but I prefer Shiri/Amy

[–] CranberryNoVodka 12 years ago

Madison is prettier to me, but Amy was pretty. The actress always looks so natural.

"You mustn't be afraid to dream a little bigger, darling."

[–] michesurflle 11 years ago

i can't believe this is even a debate. amy is way hotter than madison, and it's not even close.

[–] Thenewnexus 11 years ago

Relax its just an opinion, i actually that madison was hotter,i usually love the crazy girls in these types of movies haha,dont get wrong amy was pretty but thats it

[–] RelpScooby 11 years ago

GOOD Madison wins.....Amy you lose, come again !!!!

[–] BuffyforQAF 11 years ago

MADISON!!!

[–] Darkehmen 11 years ago

Madison, by far. She has the better figure and the prettier face.

[–] Classic_Movies7 10 years ago

Madison. Amy is ugly

[–] Rooney_Mara_Lover 8 years ago

Madison