I understand that we all have our own opinions (and I know that you realise this), but maybe saying that "you wonder how much everyone was listening while playing" is a little over-the-line, perhaps? As you say - it's all down to each individual's opinions. Just because someone prefers a "lesser" soundtrack to a "better" one, it doesn't mean that they somehow lack the ability to discern what is "good music", it just means they have a differing opinion.
Anyway, trivialities aside - Tactics I haven't played, so I honestly can't talk about the quality of the music. And I know it will sound very fanboyish of me, but in my opinion (and in my own experience), most Final Fantasy soundtracks that haven't majorly featured Nobuo Uematsu composing tend to be of a lesser quality. I can think of quite a few tracks from Final Fantasy X that are pretty bad - the final battle music, for instance ("Decisive Battle"). As soon as the dramatic introduction ends, the some fast piano-work comes in - and from that moment on, everything seems a little...messy. It also gets very repetitive - I've just checked the mp3 I have of it, and it seems to loop only after about 2 minutes or so.
And "Scorching Desert", too - it begins to grate on my nerves just with the first thirty seconds of it. It's that constant synthesised couple of notes that play over and over and over again that get me.
Thinking about it, one of the major things I have against the music of FFX is that sure, it's atmospheric where it needs to be, but it can't have been that difficult to compose. If you listen to "Darkness", say, that seems to consist of the same drumbeat looped over and over again, with a couple of string chords changing in the background. It doesn't take a genius composer to come up with something like that. And thinking about it some more, another reason I don't like it is because the music is too experimental (again, "Scorching Desert") for my tastes. A lot of it (e.g. "Fog Sea") doesn't seem to be music, more of a collection of sounds with a bunch of effects thrown in.
And if it's any indication to the quality of the music from X-2: http://ffmusic.ffshrine.org/ff10-2sheet/ff10-2-sheet-music.php You can see how little sheet music there is - the entire soundtrack doesn't seem to be music, more of a collection of sounds.
And from what I've played of FFXII, the music seems to be pretty good. Granted, currently I can't remember any of it, but I remember it being pretty good nonetheless.
In terms of musical quality, though - my ranking changes:
1. FFVII
2. FFIX
3. FFX / FFVIII (I can't decide)
5. FFX-2
...and I'm reserving judgement on FFXII until I've played a little more. (though it's good to see that they've brought back the main Final Fantasy theme. )
Kupokupo has mentioned some of the greater tracks from FFIX, and I can list a load more of my favourites - Feel My Blade!, Frontier Village Dali, the Treno theme, Eternal Harvest, Unfathomed Reminiscence, Protecting my Devotion, the Hilda Garde theme...
"Smells like crotch."
reply
share