MovieChat Forums > Valentine (2001) Discussion > How would you rank the girls looks wise?...

How would you rank the girls looks wise?

posted 17 years ago by roxysoccerbabe11
71 replies | jump to latest

I was just watching this movie with my boyfriend and we got to talking about how we would rank the girls in order of attractiveness (shallow, I know) and we both agreed that Shelley was the prettiest and then our orders differed after that so I was just wondering what everyone else thought. If I were putting them in order from prettiest to least I would say:

Shelley
Kate
Paige
Dorothy
Lily

[–] Cujo108 9 years ago

Lily
Paige
Ruthie
Kate
Dorothy
Shelley

[–] Wildstyle26 9 years ago

I would say

1. Kate
2. Lilly
3. Shelby
4. Paige
5. Dorothy

[–] Anrachman 9 years ago

Kate
Shelley
Paige
Lily
Dorothy

[–] 9 years ago

[deleted]

[–] prolelol (1428) 4 years ago

1. Pagie, she was smokin' hot
2. Shelley
3. Kate
4. Lily
5. Dorothy

[–] Wuchak (8855) 3 years ago

Dorothy
Kate
Shelley
Lily
Paige

[–] SkyeRiley (332) 8 days ago

Shelley (plump Katherine Heigl)
Paige (Denise Richards)
Kate (Marley Shelton)
Dorothy (Jessica Capshaw)
Lily (Jessica Cauffiel)