MovieChat Forums > Valentine (2001) Discussion > How would you rank the girls looks wise?...

How would you rank the girls looks wise?


I was just watching this movie with my boyfriend and we got to talking about how we would rank the girls in order of attractiveness (shallow, I know) and we both agreed that Shelley was the prettiest and then our orders differed after that so I was just wondering what everyone else thought. If I were putting them in order from prettiest to least I would say:

Shelley
Kate
Paige
Dorothy
Lily

reply

Shelley
Kate
Lily
Paige
Dorothy

reply

Kate
Shelley
Paige
Lily
Dorothy

...I think :P

--
Previously pezzer4eva & pezz_ah :)

reply

Kate (Marley Shelton) was definitely the best looking one of the girls.

reply

paige
Shelly
Kate
Dorothy
lily

reply



Shelly
Kate
Paige
Dorthy
Lily

Valentine GREAT FILM terribly underratted

reply

Shelley
Kate
Paige
Lily
Dorothy

Do you understand the words that are comin' out of my mouth!?!

reply

lets be realistic here.. you people are ranking Katherine Heigl's character based on how hot she is NOW. she is in no way hotter than denise richards in THIS movie.

reply

Paige
Shelley
Lily
Kate
Dorothy

reply

Paige
Kate
Dorothy
Shelley
Lily

Close only counts with horseshoes, hand grenades, and thermo-nuclear weapons.

reply

Shelley
Paige
Kate
Lily
Dorothy

It's an ordinary high school day. Except that it's not.

reply

Paige
Kate
Lily
Shelley
Dorothy

"They want to exterminate us!"-X3

reply

lily
paige
kate
shelly
dorothy

reply

Kate
Paige
Lily
Shelley
Dorothy

Regards,
TheGodAwfulTruth. xoxo

reply

1) Paige
2) Shelly
3) Kate
4) Dorothy
5) Lily

reply

1) Shelley
2) Paige
3) Kate
4) Lily
5) Dorothy

Rest In Pieces
8/28/2009

reply

Wow. You people must be a bunch of Katherine Chain Smoker Heigl fanboys and fangirls. I'd rank her last.

reply

Heigl's a chubster in this flick.

reply

Heigl's a chubster in this flick.

its morons like you who make girls have eating disorders. your probably a tub of lard sitting at home on your fAT ass wishing you could ever look as good as she did in that movie.. she looks better then then now.. and if you're a guy are you just sad because a girl like that will never ever go for you? get a life.. moron

reply

Yeah this is me projecting my insecurities. How did you know?

reply

Yeah this is me projecting my insecurities. How did you know?


It's pretty obvious, actually.

reply