Why did Alison dislike Elliot in these wishes...

I think because having all that money and power as a colombian wasn't enough for her and she shunned him for Raul...IMHO it says more about womens fussyness in choosing and seeing what they like in a guy than Elliots attempt to woo her lol.

Seems to me Elliot was a jack of all trades in personality and characters BUT he was a MASTER of ONE!!....Rich & powerful, Mr Sensitivity, Mr Articulate, Mr Sporting etc etc

She was really into him in the basketball one until she sees him naked and finds out that has a comically small penis. It's implied that she's more of a sports-star-groupie than a good relationship prospect in that one. After seeing his winkie she says that she had to go because she's got to work on a "big, huge" story about the NFL.

SnowFairy, I could be wrong, but here's what I think...when he was the drug lord, she hated him for the same reason Tony Soprano's wife hated him...all that money and power and how corrupt he was. And when he was the bastketball player, she at first was into him, but turned him down when she saw how small his...member was.

Oh I don't know, maybe cause the wishes are being granted by THE DEVIL !!!

remember how these wishes dont only change his life of the present, but his past and everyone around him change as well.

example:

Elliot´s life as the drug dealer, we dont know how he came to be as a drug dealer nor how he married allison, for all we know, elliot´s alter self (himself in the wish world) had forced her to marry him, maybe his alter self was also abusive, we dont know. as we see, elliot does not remember anything prior appearing in the wish world, so his past (in this world) even to him is a mistery

example 2:

Elliot wishes he could be the most sensitive man in the world cause he thinks thats what allison wants, this is in fact an example of how people dont always know what they want and how to much of something is a bad thing

as for the basketball scene, she didnt want elliot cause she saw his, well she saw that his junk was too small, maybe smaller than a pinky, because it freaked elliot out, hell any guy would get freaked out if they woke up and saw their mini-me´s have shrunken to an insignificant size.

Columbian Drug Lord-She became bored with him and more than likely the off camera Elliott was probably a douche to her. People of his power ar enot usually good to their women. Just watch Scarface.

Sensitive Elliott-She initially fell in love with a sensitive man but Elliott proved to be TOO sensitive. What she really wanted was what she got in Bob and that's someone to get into her pants.

NBA Star Elliott-She was enamored with him at first until she got a good look at his, erm, equipment. This was an instant turn off.

Rich, Successful Raconteur Elliott-She became instantly attracted to him but as it turned out he was gay(not a flaming homosexual. That would be his boy toy played by Toby Huss).

Elliott Lincoln-As historically inaccurate this scene was(Mary Todd was at his side at Ford's), Alison was enamored with the president.

That's the relationship in a nutshell.

It wasn't really Alison in any of the wishes. They were just scenarios designed to be painful and destructive by the devil.

Because Alison is a selfish shallow narcissic conceited BITCH!