MovieChat Forums > Todo sobre mi madre (2000) Discussion > Ridiculous vastly over-rated National En...

Ridiculous vastly over-rated National Enquirer-fed tragedy


Although this movie was well acted, the story is simply far too incredible to promote any sort of sympathy for the characters. Every character has a trait more common to outlandish soap operas than to dramatic films; a half-man, half-woman cross-dressing heroin-addicted AIDS-infested prostitute, an aging lesbian diva in love with a heroin-addicted actress young enough to be her granddaughter, a suffering wife of a completely addled husband with Alzeimer's estranged from her daughter, a tragic mother of a recently deceased 17-year old son, another half-man half-woman prostitute who spends the better part of the film speaking of his/her job-related exploits, and a preposterous nun who sleeps with the most unlikely of "men" to not only get pregnant but to also contract HIV. The cast of characters is just so ridiculous as to only be found in a very unrealistic episode of "Days of Our Lives".

It is obvious that Aldomovar was just going for the "Cannes Film Festival storyline", whose prize recipients always includes such improbable relationships and destructive character flaws. Why can't the story simply be about a woman trying to deal with the death of her son? No, that would not have won any accolades, so the entire cast of "very left of mainstream" characters had to be thrown in so that every reviewer in our Politically Correct times could not possibly pan it for fear of being labeled a bigot. How can the audience possibly accept that a nun presumably devoted enough to her order as to accept a dangerous humanitarian mission to war-torn El Salvador, would sleep with a known man/woman prostitute who has been a heroin addict for 15 years? What happened to her vows? What happened to her common sense? What in the world was the attraction????? The site of "Lola" at the nun's funeral near the end of the movie was more pathetic than tragic, no woman on the planet would possibly consider such a mate (nor would they even likely consider that person a man). It was simply so impossible to conceive that it was ridiculous.

Finely acted but preposterous tripe.

R.

reply

"Why can't the story simply be about a woman trying to deal with the death of her son?"

Then you would be on this site complaining that its too cliche. You may not want to believe it but tranvestites do exist. The movie is different. It wasn't suppose to be about reality. What? Just because there wasn't fairy dust or three headed monsters in the movie it cannot be fiction?
You should see more Almodovar films to realize that he has been coming up with strange combinations since way before his movies were known internationally. Some diretors (like some in the U.S.) make movies for pure entertainment to get money. For other directors making movies is an artform with a need to be shared with the world for the purpose to make people think. You obviously want something simple. From what I'm reading I think this movie was too complex for you. You haven't seen nothing yet. Hasn't there been a moment in your life that was full of chaos? If you felt that you couldn't handle the amount of elements in this movie then I don't know how you are gonna survive when you see movies that deal with rape, sex, drugs (not the ones that are presented in comedies).


I'm human and I need to be loved.

reply

I thought this movie was crap. Wasn't worth the film it was shot on. However, I'm going to see other Almodovar movies, perhaps they'll make a difference.

reply

Andrei, If you think this brilliant film was 'crap' dont waste any more of your hard-earned to see another Almovodar film. You'll never get it. Just stick with the real crap in your local cinema complex. Cheers

reply

ITS A MOVIE!!!!!!!!!

reply

[deleted]