MovieChat Forums > Patch Adams (1998) Discussion > WHY does nobody like this movie?

WHY does nobody like this movie?


Honestly, I can't wrap my mind around the fact that I can only find about 2 other people who like this movie.

I'm one of those people who cry at everything (and by everything I mean legit everything, including jewelry commercials) and of course, I was bawling from the second the film started right up until the end. I absolutely love it.

I understand the sap-factor of the movie and that it is melodramatic at certain parts, but I feel like it's necessary! Is that the only reason people don't like it? Because I honestly don't think it was a poorly made movie in the least. The acting is great, the part is perfect for Williams, and I think the script is at least decent. The monologue on the cliff is amazing. If you don't like sappy movies, that's your problem, but that's the only reason I've gotten so far as to why people dislike Patch Adams, but almost everyone says they hate the movie.

Can someone please fill me in on reasons people don't like this?! It's a mystery to me, honestly.

reply

2 Words

Robin Williams

reply

I think it depends on whether you like the character of Patch Adams. Honestly, I wish there were more people like him who care so wholeheartedly about people and wants to solve their problems, and he finds that making them laugh works. It may not always works, but it's the method he uses, because he sees it work in people, and he has a medical facts to back it up (I love the scene where he explains it to Walcott, how laughter creates a positive immune system response). Yes, the film is manipulative, and it tugs at your heartstring, but I love it because I enjoy watching this character work, interact with people, make people laugh, and there are scenes that really make me laugh as well. Also, I'm a longtime fan of Robin Williams, and I love watching him improvise (I believe the speech at the meat packers convention was improvised). I also love the message, which is not to be indifferent to people just because we're fighting a disease. It's about people as well as diseases, and even though the message is brought home so many times throughout the film, it's a valuable message. That's my opinion.

reply

Indeed. We probably all know of at least one doctor who is very cold, impersonal, and treats his patients like they're just wasting his time. I like what Patch said when they were holding the hearing, that they shouldn't wait until they've lost their humanity, their ability to communicate with other people. And I remember what he said early on about he spent a whole day calling random phone numbers, and it makes you wonder, what exactly did he say to those people? And I imagine some hanged up immediately on him but others probably stayed on the line to talk a good long while.

reply

I have actually had that happen many times before from back when I was at work and when I was home. Many where elderly people who had the wrong number and even with the wrong number, there was something in my accent (Georgia accent) and the manner in which I speak that made them think I was a family member or other loved one but when I told them they had the wrong number and wrong person, they would apologize and I always assured them they had no reason to apologize. I've even helped many find the right number they were trying to dial but were off by a digit or simply dialed the number wrong.

In all honesty, some of the most wonderful conversations I've had were with people, young and old, who simply dialed the wrong number and got me. And yes, we have sat on the phone talking for as high as 30mins to an hour. Although, the most satisfying conversations took place with elderly people who had so few family members alive to talk to at any time; I guess I served as some sort of surrogate for them and that is okay b/c by the time we hung up from that wrong number dial, I could hear the joy in their voices. Nobody wants to be alone all the time; hwr, many elderly people and shut ins are alone a lot with nobody to care about them enough to pick up a phone or stop by for a visit and that is so sad & wrong.

After my grandfather died (complications of his heart, kidneys, type II diabetes, & severe Parkinson's Disease - not to mention he was in his late 80s to early 90s & raised 7 children who never came to see him after they stuck him in a nursing home so they didn't have to deal with him despite the fact he was functional and walking 5-miles each day when it wasn't raining, attended church & gospel singing functions and had several women who gladly picked him up b/c he was unable to drive anymore, which I am thankful for b/c I'm NOT A CHRISTIAN & I know I'd never been able to handle sitting through those services or programs b/c we had very separate spiritual beliefs & he never dismissed them nor dishonored my beliefs... after about 2yrs in the nursing home & couldn't get permission to go out walking, not even with an orderly or volunteer, he ended up in a wheelchair from the lack of being allowed his former activities - he ultimately died from old age & people forgetting that he was a real person - not cattle to be prodded from room to room like a child when he was a very wise man with lots to teach others if only they'd listen... He was one of the most difficult men I lost in my life & it hurts even more when I think of the reasons that set him on the course of dying much younger than he would have if left to live in his own home & resume his own activities. It wasn't as if he didn't have healthcare that would cover a nurse coming out a couple hours a day to check his vitals and go through his medications to ensure he had all of them & were taking them. Hell, I'd have done it for free!

Even after his death, I continued my visits to the nursing home 2-3 times a week and visits with my children over the weekends to continue coming by to see his friends who were as elderly and even more forgotten than my grandfather was b/c he always had me, my children, & a younger sibling I practically raised his entire life. It makes a difference - It really does.

Today, my oldest daughter works in the medical field, runs a side business, married, & working on her graduate degree, which will be her 4th degree all totaled so far but she still dressing in these beautiful gowns & visits the respite center she worked at for quite a long time while in college before having to move closer to another college b/c the one she attended didn't offer what she needed but she still comes back to sing for them a few times a month as a volunteer just as she sang for them a few times a month when she was there taking care of them. She sings at another respite center she worked at near her previous college as well. Her one sadness she carries with her is when she gets the calls when one of patients has passed away, esp her favorites who took to her as a surrogate grandparent or great-grandparent. She says it's one of the most difficult things about going back to sing for them b/c it's as if there's this emptiness in the room from the loss of those who are gone. The families of some of the ones who passed on have even had her sing at the memorial services. It helps the family and it helps her grieve so she can move forward by carrying the wonderful memories shared, lessons learned, & just overall being a part of that person's life along w/learning how much she truly touched that person's life & didn't know it.

So yes, there is validity to missed dialed calls. Overall, I believe people are inherently good but I can't say that without adding that there are always those bad apples that are always attempting to spew their personal spray of venom b/c they lack or refuse to let others into their lives that will always spoil a few in the bunch.

reply

I found the first part of the movie heart-warming and wonderful until Patch gets involved in the relationship with a woman. Then I lost my interest in the story.

reply

I am a 20 year old Long Islander, going into medicine myself. Regardless of realism or whatever you people are blabbering about, it was just a movie, and one of my favorite movies of all time.

reply

Gotta admit, whether it's realistic or not, Patch has certainly managed to make it work for him and all of his partners in the medical business and all the people he visits with. So apparently he got something right in his theory about how the medical profession should work.

reply

There are somewhere in the neighborhood of a few dozen doctors just in my area locally who are on the waiting list to work with Patch Adams when the care center/hospital is built and one of those happens to be a close friend to Patch. He was even in the movie. Furthermore, he was my late grandfather's doctor for many, many years.

FYI: He is one of the last few doctors who will treat patients whether they can pay him or not and that's a rarity. we have lost 2 other doctors that I have seen personally when I was so sick I could barely drive let alone work and had no insurance at the time yet these few doctors treated me without ever sending a bill or caring more about the money than the patient's well-being.

reply

When "Patch Adams" first came out in 1998, I allowed Roger Ebert's 1.5 star review to prejudice me against the movie. So for years, I passed over it in the rental store, until my wife brought it home from the library. Sure it's "mawkish" (a word used in the movie itself) but it had so many LOL moments. Its pace was uneven, but this often happens in "Based on a True Story" movies, and I enjoyed it. Maybe because my Dad was a doctor, and he would sing to his patients, rather than use humour, to help his patients feel better. Many a Christmas Eve, our whole family would be at the hospital singing carols. He also had a special connection with children. BTW, another movie I enjoyed that was panned by the critics was Steve Martin's Pink Panther movie (haven't seen the second one yet).

reply

When "Patch Adams" first came out in 1998, I allowed Roger Ebert's 1.5 star review to prejudice me against the movie. So for years, I passed over it in the rental store, until my wife brought it home from the library. Sure it's "mawkish" (a word used in the movie itself) but it had so many LOL moments. Its pace was uneven, but this often happens in "Based on a True Story" movies, and I enjoyed it. Maybe because my Dad was a doctor, and he would sing to his patients, rather than use humour, to help his patients feel better. Many a Christmas Eve, our whole family would be at the hospital singing carols. He also had a special connection with children. BTW, another movie I enjoyed that was panned by the critics was Steve Martin's Pink Panther movie (haven't seen the second one yet).

reply

Because it's horrible.

reply

this is a great movie, the real patch adams likes this movie,, these people are haters.. they dont like robin willams cuz thier jealous

reply

Actually, the real Mr. Adams has gone on record as saying he greatly dislikes this film.

reply

And when and where did he say that?

reply

http://www.chasingthefrog.com/reelfaces/patchadams.php

Not enough for you? Try looking up some videos/interviews with this guy pertaining to his feelings on the portrayal of him in this movie. Or, heck, you can even just write him.

Boom. You're welcome.

reply

I loved the movie and so does my mother and a few other people I know. I thought everything about it was great. Some below are saying it was unrealistic? Really in what way? Some people pay way too close attention to all the tiny little details rather than look at the story itself and it was a great story.

reply

Because it is not very good.

-Hey yo, listen here, Bey. You come at the King, you best not miss.

reply

Ah go blow it out your tubenburbles.

reply