MovieChat Forums > Mononoke-hime (1997) Discussion > Significantly over rated.

Significantly over rated.


I just finished watching and I think it's vastly over rated.
Maybe the intention of the director / writers was to frustrate me - because that's what the movie did. I realise having simple movies with clear antagonists and protagonists is a bit basic but this film just had me almost hating every character in the film. The only character I like was the princess and the deer god. Even the Wolf god was a bitter *beep* (understandable but bitter none the less)

I get the message that the forest and the people need to work together to have equilibrium (at least I believe that's the message) but how it's told wasn't to my liking. I guess I like my Miyazaki films to be a lot more sweet at the end or have at least some good touching moments throughout the film.
Often the childish, yet touching moments in his films bring a tear to my eye - this film didn't do that even once. I was expecting this to be some kind of epic tear jerker with some completely touching and bittersweet moments but ultimately almost every character death didn't do much for me.

I didn't dislike the film and I suspect a second viewing may help me enjoy more of it but I would give this film a 6.5 out of 10 at best to be honest.
Spirited away, a vastly more strange, less complex (emotionally) and simple film is far superior to me. It's a weird yet fantastic spectacle with some genuinely touching moments. Also Nausicaa - a Miyazaki film with some more serious and darker tones is far far better than Mononoke.

Perhaps hearing for 10 years what a great film it is has over hyped it for me or perhaps this evening I'm not in the mood for a film with no clear bad guy and distinct winner but this movie is not what I was expecting. Fantastic animation indeed, as usual but in this persons opinion definitely no where near the top of Miyazakis film list.

reply

Indeed. Too slow and gory for my taste.

Howl's > this

I bet you say that to all the Nordic ice goddesses.

reply

After seeing it at the top of most "best Studio Ghilbi movies" list my expectations were very high. I ended up being disappointed. It was just ok.

reply

Like all of Miyazaki's work, it is visually stunning but completely empty.

reply

No.

reply

Laputa: Castle in the Sky is my favorite by him. PM is, indeed, overrated but at least decent. At least 3 are better than PM.

reply

There are no where near enough people overpraising this film or even acknowledging it as great for it to be considered overrated. It's a wonderful masterpiece even today and millions more need to see it before any real distinctions of "overrated" can be made.

reply