MovieChat Forums > Donnie Brasco (1997) Discussion > Anyone else DEEPLY disturbed by the bash...

Anyone else DEEPLY disturbed by the bashing of the Japaense guy?


I've seen Donnie Brasco probably 10 times and the scene where they bash the Japanese guy in the tiolet of the Japanese restaurant never gets any easier for me. Everytime I mention this to others who have seen this film, I get the impression that nobody else is as affected by the scene as me. Anyone else find that scene DEEPLY disturbing?

reply

I enjoyed that scene.

reply

I've seen Donnie Brasco probably 10 times and the scene where they bash the Japanese guy in the tiolet of the Japanese restaurant never gets any easier for me. Everytime I mention this to others who have seen this film, I get the impression that nobody else is as affected by the scene as me. Anyone else find that scene DEEPLY disturbing?


I agree with you. More than any other scene in this genre I think that this gives a good demonstration of what brutally violent bullies these people actually are. What they did was savagely beat someone because he insisted that they honor the rules of the establishment. So far as we know this man had no connection whatsoever to the mob or any other criminal activity...he just made the mistake of insisting that this bunch of thugs respect his right to run his business the way that he choses.

reply

I did, but I found the scene more laughable than disturbing. I found it funny that all the guy wanted is that Donnie gets his shoes off, and those guys beat him up for that.

reply

No, because a) it's just a bunch of actors playing dress-up-and-pretend, and b) in real life it never happened (no mention of it in Pistone''s book).

reply

Lol, 11 years late to this thread... But, yes sort of! I was wondering if anyone mentioned it on here & looks like you did! I agree it was quite disturbing, & yeah yeah - It's just a movie, it didn't really happen, there are worse scenes out there. But idk, I was sort of shocked, i think mostly because of the dialogue, & much less the violence (i know, how weird lmao), but at the same time, not really, since it was integral to the film in a way.

reply

I looked away.

reply

No it is not a disturbing scene. More comical.

reply

The waiter could have avoided it all by just accepting that the customer wanted to keep his shoes on.

reply