MovieChat Forums > The Rock (1996) Discussion > The bad guys' motivation makes no sense ...

The bad guys' motivation makes no sense and are in no way sympathetic


Since there is no military conscription in the US since Vietnam, the bad guys had to have first volunteered to join the US Marines, and then secondly volunteered to join to join their top secret black ops team to knowingly take part in illegal wars, but they're shocked and outraged the US Government doesn't publicly admit to it whenever one of them dies.

I get the feeling you supposed to find their cause sympathetic, but it makes no sense.

reply

Maybe their cause is "Black ops casualties need recompense too!"
and they expect the gvt to make up some story about how they died and offer compensation.
Like "secret mission in the nearest 'legal' war"
or "training accident"

reply

I understand his frustration about his men not being recognised and their families not receiving pensions, but I agree, the method he chose made little sense. Taking hostages and threatening to kill hundreds of thousands of innocent people? That’s crazy.

It would have been more effective and far less homicidal if he had told his superiors “I’ve written a tell-all book with every detail about every black-ops mission my team has executed in the past twenty years, and if the families of my dead men aren’t compensated or if something happens to me, it will be sent to every newspaper in the country”. But that would be a boring movie.

reply

Well mason addressed this in the movie when he goes 'pershonally I think ur a fucking idiot , general shir'

reply