Why a 6.5?


I totally disagree with what Doug Walker has to say. I agree it is historically inaccurate but it is a great film with good characters in it. This film deserves a higher rating like a 7.4 instead of a 6.5. I mean what's all the fuss?

reply

No idea but i agree completely. Maybe it was too serious for people or something. I think it's a beautiful movie.

reply

People are idiots. Their main argument is that it is historically inaccurate, as you said, but what has that got to do with anything I ask? EVERY movie based on a true story is inaccurate and this is a freaking Disney movie, how on earth can anyone be so stupid they would expect a Disney movie to be historically accurate?

It is truly a wonderful movie with songs of gold.

reply

you know, there are many similar threads about the same topic on this board. why don't you join those instead of starting a new one??

reply

And yet you just contributed to it...

reply

shut up.

reply

No thank you.

reply

It's definitely a very underrated movie IMO. Better than Hercules or The Hunchback Of Notre Dame.

RIP
Ronnie James Dio
July 10, 1942-May 16, 2010

reply

personally i foudn this movie lame and boring growing up, and when i tried to rewatch it later in life i couldnt get through it.

its a boring movie with a simple story, if u liek it thats fine, but i never did.

most of the characters were pretty forgettable, especially the villain.

reply

Yeah, I love Doug Walker, but he can be a bit pedantic sometimes.

And calling out a Disney movie for its deviation from the source material is kinda like calling out a porno movie for showing nudity.

reply

Doug Walker is right here. (NOSTALGIA CRITIC, CHANNEL AWESOME!) For one, Pocaontas was a little girl aged to a TEENAGER, or SUPERMODEL. Even Tex Avery, at Leon Schlesinger/Warner Bros/Vitaphone (in 1938's JOHNNY SMITH AND POCAHONTAS, starroing Egghead :)),used her as a little girl..for an example..

reply

Doug Walker's (or should I say Doug WANKER) an ass hole. Period. I wouldn't listen to what that wannabe movie critic has to say. The dude's the definition of a has been given that the Nostalgia Critic fad died years ago. He's a hater not a critic.

"TAKE BACK YOUR F--KING HORSE!"-Mort Goldman (Family Guy)

reply

Should've definitely got higher.

reply

[deleted]