MovieChat Forums > Die Hard with a Vengeance (1995) Discussion > Can anybody explain the bottle riddle!

Can anybody explain the bottle riddle!


Never got it.

reply

Yes.
Fill the 3 gallon bottle and empty it into the 5 gallon. Fill it again and empty into 5 gallon until full. This leaves 1 gallon in the 3 gallon bottle. Empty all the water from the 5 gallon and pour the remaining 1 gallon from the 3 gallon into the 5 gallon. Refill the 3 gallon and pour it into the 5 gallon.
Exactly 4 gallons!!!

Gentlemen, England will be playing 4-4-f---ing-2

reply

I remember they have 2 gallons left in the 3 gallons.

That's mean, they (McClaine and Zeus, most probably off screen):-

Fill 5 gallons bottle full
Pour 3 gallons into 3 gallons bottle (5 gallons bottle have 2 gallons left)
Empty the 3 gallons bottle
Transfer the 2 gallons remaining in 5 gallons bottle to 3 gallons bottle

That's how they have 2 gallons in a 3 gallons bottle.

What they do is:-

Fill 5 gallons bottle full again
Pour 1 gallons into 3 gallons bottle

So the 5 gallons bottle will have 4 gallons.

Yours are not wrong, just not the way they did it.

reply

Yeah, I explained tge shorter (in my opinion easier) way to do it. The OP was asking the solution to the riddle, but as you say that wasn't how they did it in the movie

reply

@wears lololol that's funny how you are trying to defend your mistake by arrogantly making out you were merely answering the question of the riddle, in your opinion the 'easier' way, when your way takes longer, I count 8 steps in total, than the correct and actual easier way that they do in the movie which is 6 steps. So nah, you fail!

reply

I'm still confused. Can you please repeat this?

reply

what they should have done considering thw water they had, was fill them both half full..... that would be 2 1/2 gallons in the 5 gallon jug, and 1 1/2 in the 3 gallon jug, and then combine them.... 2 1/2 + 1 1/2 =4.... boom, they had their solution!!!

reply

[deleted]

It had to be precise to the ounce though, so that wouldn't have worked.

reply

That kind of precision does not happen with two random people lacking measuring equipment. A gallon of water weighs 8 pounds. It would be pretty easy to be off by an ounce in terms of the detonating device.

reply

what they should have done considering thw water they had, was fill them both half full..... that would be 2 1/2 gallons in the 5 gallon jug, and 1 1/2 in the 3 gallon jug, and then combine them.... 2 1/2 + 1 1/2 =4.... boom, they had their solution!!!


More like boom, there goes the entire block after the bomb goes off. They had to get precisely four gallons of water, no margin for error.

'Remember when' is the lowest form of conversation. - Tony Soprano

reply

They "explain" it in the film.

And so, God came forth and proclaimed widescreen is the best.
Sony 16:9

reply

Must admit, I didn't get it until my third viewing.

reply

This scene is so stupid, it totally halts the film, and i've seen it give trouble to many a viewer ever since it was released. Hey everybody, lets go to school! Weeee.

"I said no camels, that's five camels, can't you count?"

reply

Personally, I would have run across the street to buy a gallon container of anything.

reply

[deleted]

OH, I guess I didn't catch that part. Thanks. I wonder if I can remember the answer now! It is still a little confusing even after reading the solution!

reply

[deleted]

No, you were right the first time, the bomb that required to solve the riddle with the gallon containers had a proximity circuit too.

reply

In today's world of smartphones they would have just Googled all the answers of the riddles.

I am a very decisive person, I think.

reply

In that case the bad guy would have given them a harder riddle, one that couldn't be solved through googling. Or even easier, the bad guy had them in his control, he could have easily asked them to just drop any smartphone.

reply

Fill the 3 gallon jug, empty it into the five gallon jug. Now you have 3 gallons of water in the 5 gallon jug.

Fill up the 3 gallon jug again. Now pour 2 gallons of it into the 5 gallon jug which already has 3 gallons of water in it from before. The 5 gallon jug is now full and the 3 gallon jug has 1 gallon of water remaining in it.

Then dump the 5 gallon jug out and pour the 1 gallon of water in from the 3 gallon jug. That makes 1 gallon of water in the 5 gallon jug.

Refill the 3 gallon jug now and then pour it into the 5 gallon jug which has 1 gallon of water already in it for a grand total of 4 gallons of water in the 5 gallon jug.

reply

Can you please repeat this?

reply

just buy a 4 gallon jug and place it on the scale

reply

I know how small amount of water it takes to be an ounce. It doesn't give them much room for error in the amount of time in which they have to do it.

reply

i thought the same thing.
then i figured OK maybe that particular bomb was never meant to actually explode in the park (Simon is a soldier not a monster, remember)

but THEN they fucking use the same bomb to blow the aqueduct ..!
idk the more i watch Die Hard 3 the more i dislike it

reply

I actually like Die Hard with a Vengeance, except for this bit. I think they thought if they just said it fast and frantically, we wouldn't think about the particulars.

reply

But if you think about the particulars it makes perfect sense. This person described it accurately: https://moviechat.org/tt0112864/Die-Hard-with-a-Vengeance/58c75f506b51e905f67ef071/Can-anybody-explain-the-bottle-riddle?reply=58c75f506b51e905f67ef073

reply

Simon's goal was to kill John. He may have been hoping the bomb would do the job.

reply

Simon's problem was watching too much Batman where there are always contrived methods of offing the Dynamic Duo which always fail. But like the Batman villains they realize once the job is done so is the thrill. Failing with the satisfaction of knowing there is another chance is like emotional heroin for these bad guys.

reply