Something I never got


I love this movie. Of course, I spent many years watching it. Probably don't go a year without at least watching it once and find many other puzzling or scenes to grimace at but it is still very fun.

The one thing I never understood is why Binx, who can talk as a cat, didn't just talk to his parents? Did he develop the ability to talk over the centuries? Never realized he could talk but only make typical cat noises? Then again, if the cat talked to his parents they'd probably fling him onto an open fire pit or something. But still something I ponder...


What do you think? Lol

reply

Perhaps the first syllable he uttered was a meow (now being a cat) and didn't realize he could use his feline equipment to make human sounds, or as you said, might have taken some time to develop the talent.



Is very bad to steal Jobu's rum. Is very bad.

reply

His parents also probably left the town too. I wouldn't put it past them - They lost both of their children to the local witches.

COOKIES AND MILK!-Ed

reply

I never really thought about that, but seeing how the townspeople were so against witchcraft, they probably would have felt the need to destroy him.

reply

Seems like most likely explanation

reply

I _kinda_ get that. They would have assumed he was possessed by Satan, or at the very least in league with Satan, and killed him. A lot of people figured cats were evil back then anyway.
What I don't get is why, when Dani says "this cat can talk" and it's obvious that Dani's mom doesn't believe her "How much candy have you eaten?":0&???

reply

Oops, hit send too soon. The question is why doesn't he talk when Dani holds him up and says "this cat can talk!"? Seems like the perfect chance to make her understand that it's real.

reply

Good point. While one can argue that the reason for that is the filmmakers didn’t want the parents to be convinced by their kids and consequently they would probably go and help them fight the Sanderson sisters and make things somewhat easier for Max, Alison and Dani (resulting in a different movie), I believe Binx understandably got frightened/shy when he was put on the spot like that.

Since he was never put in this type of situation before (or who knows, maybe he was), his first instinct was to simply say nothing. It might’ve been centuries since the Sanderson sisters and Witchcraft ran amok in Salem, but considering this town very much still believed in the supernatural, I’m certain Binx knew that if he were to start talking to adults who had a hard enough time believing what their kids were telling them, then things could’ve gotten out of control. Really, who knows how Dani’s parents would have reacted? Or anyone else at that party, for that matter. I mean even if the adults saw Binx as harmless once he started talking (it’s not like he could be killed anyway), Binx had to know that talking to Dani & Max’s parents wasn’t going to solve anything.

Of course the only reason Binx talked to Max in the first place, is because he had no other choice — the possibility of him being able to talk again once the black flame candle was lit notwithstanding. Sht got real!

reply

Maybe Binx got his ability to talk when the black flame candle was lit.

Mrs Voorhees is watching you!

reply

Oh, I remember why! It wasn't until Max lit the Black Candle that Binx got his voice back. So for centuries, he was powerless to make anything more than cat noises.

reply