Something I always wondered


If Kermit and Piggy couldn't cure Tiny Tim how did Scrooge? Maybe access to better medical treatment? It just seems to me like Bob was such a good father, he would have done anything for his son.

reply

Bob and Emily would do anything legal and moral to save their son, captainbucky, but can't because they're penniless. Scrooge does not cure Tiny Tim either, but makes the youngster healthy enough to survive with proper nutrition. Tiny Tim doesn't need medicine, he just needs enough to eat.

reply

Was he just malnourished ? I thought maybe Scrooge being a rich guy could have brought in a specialist or something

reply

Yes, it's just severe malnutrition. Also, there would not be a medical specialist in the nineteenth century. Please read my response on the thread about Tiny Tim's condition. I explain there what is wrong and how it is changed.

reply

I think since the dawn of time there has been specialists. This move take place in I belive the 1840's and they had specialists in the early 1700 but I think his illness is meant to be subjective

reply

In the early days of humans, there was no concept of medicine because biology had not yet been recognized. Later there were doctors with special interests, but not ones who fit what eventually defined a specialist. In the nineteenth century physicians were all over the place in their work and handled everything.

reply

Scrooge paid for Tiny Tim's laudanum and ether from the corner store, thus making the child all better.

reply

Oh, so he bought medicine for his glabella was inflamed hens the coughing fits during bouts of excitement.
He had bats in the belfry or something?

reply

And some juvenile syphilis to boot.

reply

I also fear that his dueotinum had low levels of florentine, and that his florid count was slightly off, which would have caused a soft spot on the head

reply

Sounds possible. A big point was made about his midichlorian deficiency.

reply

Well of course back then you couldn't get midichlorian from the local ... repository or vitamin store, many of the poor had midichlorian deficiency. midichlorian was for the very rich

reply

With his income, it was irresponsible of Cratchit to have five children. To expect his employer to compensate for his bad judgment was unreasonable.

reply