Is this the Mandela Effect?

So I recently purchased the entire collection of Are you afraid of the dark, I'm on episode 7 of the first season. One of my most favorite episodes of the series....The Tale Of The Dead Mans Float. Just one issue though....why do I remember this being much later in the series? I'm talking like MUCH later....when tucker was the leader and they brought the show back after being off the air for a few years.....I even remember him bringing stigg to see if he had what it takes to be a member....stigg tasting the powder lol....the whole gang voting no after he told like one of the best stories ever....and I thought It was BS....but this was the 7th episode in the series???? WTF