the novel vs the movie


the movie is so different from the novel written by nancy price. I had just finished reading the novel yesterday. in the novel, the drowned woman is actually called Sara Burney and then she changes her name to Laura Pray after she fakes her death and moves to a new city. in the novel, Sara is constantly wearing her wig so that no one recognizes her. She is shown to be financially broke and she is constantly hungry and wants to eat. She is shown to be very skinny and her body is full of bruises resulting from the constant physical abuses by her psycho husband. When Sara goes to visit her mother in a nursing home, she acts a lot smarter than Julia Roberts' character in the movie. She says to the nursing home receptionist that she is visiting another woman in the nursing home while she is actually here to visit her mom as to avoid anyone suspecting her to be alive. in the novel, Sara doesn't say anything to Ben about her previous life. Ben didn't even bother to ask her a lot of questions unlike the character of Kevin Anderson in the movie. in the novel, Ben is showed to be more compassionate and understanding. In the novel, Martin has a hard time catching on to what his wife really did. He almost kills a trespasser mistaking him for Ben Woodward. And the major difference between the book and the movie is in the book, Martin commits suicide while in the movie he is killed off by Julia Roberts.

reply


I loved the book too, I've read it several times.

You should really put a *Spoiler* tag in your thread title, its just nicer in case people don't realize & want to read the book.

"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

oh! i am really sorry. that was really stupid on my part to do that! i am sorry if i ruined the novel for anybody. i wasn't thinking right that time!!! my apologies!!!

reply


That's OK. I've done that accidentally a couple times myself.

You can just Edit your original post: Add *spoiler* to the title.


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

Suicide? I thought she killed him. Edit: Oh wow, nope, he did shoot himself. Wow..

In any case, your comment about Ben being more compassionate and understanding in the book is total bunk. He was less pushy at first, which is good, but he was also very fussy about her fitting his standards of a future wife. Whine whine whine, Laura wouldn't open more with him, boohoo..

reply


I agree, whitespirit. Ben was just as much if not more of a punk, in the book.
He says things (to himself only but still) like if he married Laura and she wanted to go to college, he'd LET her. Or thinking of Laura as his wife, 'someone who belonged to him.'
He got angry from the start just because Laura kept him at arm's length. UM, back off...its HER perogative!

He was a sexist pig, just like Martin.


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

Amen. Martin was more than a pig, he was a person with serious problems, but Ben had his own borish edges to work out.

reply


Oh I agree, I wasn't saying Martin was only a sexist pig lol!
He was a control freak OCD wife-beating psychopath! He had no redeeming qualities whatsoever in my book, while Ben at least tried to help Laura (in the movie, in the book he was useless).


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

LOL, true. At least he gave her some space in the book, not nagging her, but I don't get why she'd settle for him.

reply

He was a control freak OCD wife-beating psychopath! He had no redeeming qualities whatsoever in my book
So OCD sufferers are freaks are they? Having OCD is akin to being a wife-beater and a psychopath.

In my book you have no redeeming qualities, and you really need to check your ignorance/privilege.

reply


Um, guy, nobody said OCD people were freaks.
Martin was a wife-beating freak who happened to HAVE OCD.

Relax.


"I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus."
"Didn't he discover America?"
"Penfold, shush."

reply

This is what the previous poster said:

He was a control freak OCD wife-beating psychopath! He had no redeeming qualities whatsoever in my book

If whitespirit26 wasn't seeking to cast aspersions on people with OCD why even bring it up when he made the point about the character having 'no redeeming qualities'? By the way he phrased it he's equating OCD with control freakery and worse, wife-beating, as if to say "no one should want to marry someone who has is a wife-beater and/or has OCD".

And just to be 100% clear I'm not suggesting that whitespirit26 was saying that people with OCD are wife-beaters, but that he's suggesting that OCD is as bad a quality as wife-beating.

reply

Are you sure about the suicide? It has been a long time since I read the book but I thought that Sara used Ben's car to drive to the hotel where she confronted Martin while wearing her her masculine disguise. Martin is confused by a man who tells him that he had loved him and he realizes that the bearded stranger has Sara's eyes.

reply

Yes, Martin committed suicide.
But the author Nancy Price writes it in one of the silliest ways I've EVER seen in a novel.
(paraphrasing slightly) Martin's head wobbled like a pumpkin. Martin's clever hands had the gun. They broke the pumpkin.
WHAT?! While the lines following make it clear what he did, the way she wrote it was quite bizarre.



I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus.
Didn't he discover America?
Penfold, shush.

reply

I can definitely see why they would change this for the film. It just wouldn't be as suspenseful/scary if Martin turned the gun on himself rather than on Laura and Ben. As a kid, him suddenly grabbing the gun and pointing it at her face scared the sh!t out of me. I laugh at a lot of this movie now and consider it a guilty pleasure, but that was well-done for the first time viewing, as were the cans being perfectly stacked in the cupboard.

reply

Agreed. It wouldn't have worked at all if Martin committed suicide.

It didn't fit with the character here either. The Martin in the novel was quite different than Martin of the film.

While, oddly, the Martin of the novel was more abusive physically...the film's Martin was much more icy-cold emotionally.

The ego of despicable movie-Martin would never have *allowed* for such a selfless act as suicide.
Lastly the audience, understandably, really "needed" to see hapless Laura give him his just desserts!



I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus.
Didn't he discover America?
Penfold, shush.

reply

Why did martin commit suicide?? And what happened to sara/laura at the end of the book?

reply

Actually, people who behave similarly to Martin are prone to indulge in suicidal ideation. I haven't read it, but my guess is that he did it out of guilt because he realized Laura would never take him back after what he did to her? I agree with everyone here about Martin in the movie though. If movie Martin ever decided to commit suicide, he would have most certainly taken Laura out first because he would never forgive her. I guess she lived happily ever after?

reply

thx for you reply. Interesting take on the film. I wish I had read the book but it was changed.

reply

See this all the time with movies based on a book and when they change something for the movie people think that the movie is how the book is.

reply