MovieChat Forums > The Silence of the Lambs (1991) Discussion > They couldn't make this film today

They couldn't make this film today


The killer is a man who wants to be a woman.

reply

Today, Buffalo Bill would be the misunderstood hero... Uh, heroine... I mean, protagonist.

reply

they would do the Disney Thing?

reply

Sure! If the current Disney epic features a puppy-skinner, it's just a very short step for them to glorify a people-skinner next!

reply

That is sadly true. George Floyd was a career criminal who is now treated as some kind of saint.

reply

Saying it was wrong to murder someone by kneeling on them for nine minutes does not make them anything but a murder victim. You should stop treating Floyd like a saint.

reply

Yep and Katherine Martin and Clarice Starling would be the oppressors who don’t understand what Buffalo Bill is going through. Katherine having a problem with being kidnapped and scalped would be seen as evidence of white privilege or something.

reply

Johnathan Demme took unbelievable shit for this film but redeemed himself in the minds of the gay trans community with Philadelphia.

At least the psychopaths are all white males.

reply

Because white males are able to plan ahead.

reply

Oooof!

reply

No, I think the backlash would be about the same as it was at the time. It generated a lot of protest from certain groups back then, but like now it was only the militants who made a fuss. Measured people realised it was just a movie and not necessarily an anti-trans statement by having a killer who was gender confused.

reply

I'm not sure what backlash you are referring too as there was no internet, social medias and cancel culture back in 1991. The Wikipedia article mentions some LGBT groups criticizing the movie but the the only actual source cited by Wikipedia is a New York Times article from 1993.

reply

I think you're right. I watched this movie in theater today and the audience wasn't sure how to react to the transsexual/transvestite parts. Never mind that folks like Ed Gein exist in the real world...

reply

I disagree; it could be made today.....though I don't think the line from the book where Hannibal tells Clarice what Buffalo Bill is up to would make the movie just it did not in Silence...

reply

same for Sleepaway Camp.

reply

The bad guy would probably be changed to a straight man (would most likely still be white).

Clarice would be the smartest character and would be able to solve the case without any previous experience, doing a better and more efficient job than others who have decades experience and studies than her.

reply

She would also be bisexual, in a relationship with a young black lesbian.

reply

She’d have no need for Hannibal Lecter as she’d already have all the answers and none of the fears. Just a badass agent the best the bureau has ever seen. Who also twerks.

reply

Today Democrats and their lemmings celebrate mental illness.

reply