Did he?


Close to the end when Birdlace ripped up Roses address, why did he do that i thought he liked her so why did he do that?

reply

I was wondering the same thing. I don't know.

I died then I thought of you and came back to life.
How can you think if you're dead?

reply

I'd like it for someone to give an opinion on it, though.....

I died then I thought of you and came back to life.
How can you think if you're dead?

reply

As a former member of the military, I can say that sometimes we meet people in a place that we have little chance of going to again. It's kinda like a fantasy romance. Promises are made to keep in touch, addresses are given, etc. But hardly ever do we follow up on those promises. Maybe a letter or two, but long distance relationships with someone you've known for 1 night don't generally work. Also, he had to save face with his buddies and never let them know he went out seriously with his "dog", so he destroyed the evidence.

BTW I "accidentally" watched the movie a couple of months ago and thought it was really great.. one of the best movies I've seen in a long time.

reply

I felt that he threw the address away because he thought after getting to know her that she was to good for him and assumed that she would move on and get married while he was away. He did it because he thought he would never have opportunity with her again.

I don't wanna kill you, but I will cuz I don't like you much anyways

reply

I think he just let his friend's b.s. get in the way of what he knew he wanted. He suffered a "relapse" of sorts when he meets back up with them. However, he has learned something about people and about women, and that is why I believe(stop reading if you don't want the ending spoiled!!) he is the only one who survives in the end.

reply

The impression I got was that he couldn't go off to war with it. He had to seperate these too things. She was something that wasn't fake, unlike his friends. He could really count on Rose. I doubt that he would go back to her after everything in Vietnam. The assiation would be too much for him.

Cheers!

reply

his friends were totally real. that's the whole significance of the tattoos. the bees. remember when Berson got Eddy's, cos Eddy was out with the dog? Well Eddy got 3 extra bees after his 3 best friends in the world died. out of loyalty.

reply

In addition to the helpful comments posted in response to your question, one might also add the "discarding the address" is a convenient narrative device--people sometimes forget they are watching a story, which requires the author(s) to fiddle with things. Had he not discarded her address, then we would assume they would have been writing to each other during his 'Nam tour. We WOULD assume they were writing, but we don't want them to be writing (for the added impact of their re-union). The most economical way to show that they totally lost contact for this period is for him to throw out her address, on screen, so we could see it happen. It is a wholly understandable thing for him to do (as a character) for the reasons cited by others who have replied to your question. Those explanations however only go halfway to justifying it. The other half of the explanation is in the fact that the character is a character in a play that requires certain narrative devices to make the story happen effectively.

reply

I just bought the DVD recently because I hadn't seen it in 13 years and had totally forgotten about the address being thrown away, but I totally agree with lumis on this.

"We WOULD assume they were writing, but we don't want them to be writing (for the added impact of their re-union)."

Throwing away Rose's address really made the last scene more emotionally poignant.

I agree even moreso now with the way they shot the last scene (even though the first time I saw it, I sort of had wished for them to have dialogue...).

reply

i thought the same thing "why didn't they say anything at the end!" but i realize they didn't have to... no words made the scene work fine

reply

It was to prove to the audience that he had no intention of keeping in touch with her.

reply

Remember that he was still a young guy, too, and young guys often act first, think later. I believe he really DID like Rose, but he didn't yet understand the impact that she had made in his life. He had changed forever in that one night, but he either didn't know that yet or didn't want to accept it. So he threw the address away to 1) prove [to his buddies and to himself] that he was still the same carefree Eddie he always was, and 2) to discredit the feelings for Rose he didn't want to accept yet. (This is my opinion, anyway....take it or leave it. :)

reply

[deleted]

"Close to the end when Birdlace ripped up Roses address, why did he do that i thought he liked her so why did he do that?"

Goofball machismo.

reply

remember what he told his friend while they were shipping out? he said that they were both bullsh@@%ers. he was bullsh***ing himself when he told her he'd write her. in other words, who was he fooling? no one.
loved the ending, though.

vince

reply

In the original script it was suppose to end at him throwing away the address - everything after that was a Hollywood add on.

reply