MovieChat Forums > The Reflecting Skin (1990) Discussion > Could somebody recommend a film in the s...

Could somebody recommend a film in the same spirit as Reflecting Skin?


I enjoyed this film very much, the slow pace, the disturbing
theme and how the landscape had a large role in the film.
I haven't seen many other films like this, others than Urga (the Sign of Love I think is the English title) and the Winterguest, Alan Rickman's beautiful film.

Please, tell me some names of other films like these!

There are many films that are set in a beautiful landscape but where this is used more as a sidescene than something that is central to the story.
The whole film can limp because the characters in a film are set in an environment they don't react to or seem like a part of. For some reason some epic films set in the countryside have stepped into this trap.


reply

I agree with you concerning the unbelievable and disturbing beauty of Philip Ridleys masterpiece. Just watched "Io non ho paura" ("I´m not scared") yesterday and was intrigued, in how many ways this movie reminded me of "The reflecting skin". Beautifully shot, yet still disturbing and filmed entirely from the sight of the kids, you should find everything in here, that you loved about "Reflecting Skin". Enjoy!

reply

[deleted]

Another film that intelligently uses the landscape to evoke atmosphere is the masterful "Days of Heaven". Although it doesn't have the surrealist touches of Reflecting Skin it has the same elegaic atmosphere and is well worth checking out

reply

Try ' The Other. ' Novel by Tom Tryon. Very similar in pace, visuals. Has a set of identical 12-yr-olds and there is a twist. You will enjoy it.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Thank you, Skin and Bones and all the others.

Some of your recommendations I have seen before, some I have found thanks to you and there are many that you have mentioned but I haven't found yet. I'll keep looking.

I found "Io non ho paura" on dvd recently, now thats a disturbing and beautiful film. "Days of Heaven" was another recommendation I got from here and actually bought, the landscape is beautifully used in the film. "Picnic at Hanging Rock" I have seen before and loved. It is one of scariest films I have seen, with that broad daylight and the sense of fear...

Passion of Darkly Noon, have I also seen before. That's a twisted little film, but didn't touch me in the same way as Reflecting Skin.
I'm a huge fan of both Lynch and Cronenberg. The other mentioned directors I have only seen a few films by. There are some trouble minded films made among those directors ;-)

So thanks again for your recommendations, I'll keep looking. If it just wasn't so difficult, even Pasolinis most famous films are almost impossible to find (for renting or at the libraries).

reply

some other highly recommended titles
1.Dont Look Now(PARAMOUNT DVD)
2.Goerge Washington(CRITERION DVD)
3.Badlands(WARNER DVD)
4.Onibaba(CRITERION DVD)
5.Kwaidan(CRITERION DVD)
6.Walkabout(CRITERION DVD)
7.Black Narcissus(CRITERION DVD)
8.Peeping Tom(CRITERION DVD)
9.Aguirre Wrath Of God(ANCHOR BAY DVD)
10.Fitzcarraldo(ANCHOR BAY DVD)
11.The Wicker Man(ANCHOR BAY DVD)
12.Sisters(CRITERION DVD)
13.The Innocents (This is perhaps the greatest film ever made and was just released in August 2005 for $14.95, so pick it up)
14.Wise Blood (OOP VIDEOTAPE)
15.Black Sunday by Mario Bava(IMAGE, MARIO BAVA COLLECTION DVD)
16.Once Upon A Time In The West (PARAMOUNT DVD)
17.92 In The Shade (OOP VIDEOTAPE)
18.Bring Me The Head Of Alfredo Garcia(MGM DVD for $11.95!)
19.Sante Sangre (You can find this on at www.exploitedcinema.com)
20.Black Sabbath (IMAGE, MARIO BAVA COLLECTION DVD)
Whew!
I hope everyone can find all of the films on this list, even though they are quite different than "The Reflecting Skin" They are all masterpieces!
Peace

reply

you've obviously done your homework, I've seen most of your list. As for your reference to Pan & Scan, you're right; DON'T BOTHER!, agreed, thx for info, Bob Lantz

reply

Nice list joncacy , the ones ive seen i like so the ones i have not i will see. Thanks , Same for the other suggestions here.

reply

You have excellent taste! I might add "The Baby," "The Killing Kind" and "The Haunting of Julia"/"Full Circle."

reply

A worthy addition - Augustin Villaronga

reply

"the butcher boy" - Neil Jordan

reply

One more in the same vein: Paperhouse (1989, I think)---British, I think, but I haven't seen it since it came out. Has the childhood fantasy/horror plot element, and pretty atmospheric, too. Worth a look.
Also, this is a little askew to that theme, but Jan Svankmajer's (sp?) Alice has a nicely dark tone to the very familiar story.

Hope that helps, and thanks everyone else for all the recommendations. My Netflix queue just grew....

reply

Although it's not out until later this year, I recommend Terry Gilliam's Tideland. They sound spookily similar!! They're both set out in middle-America, the main character is a kid with an overactive imagination, and they have a strange neighbour. And they're both set in America, but both shot in Canada. Coincidence??

reply

uutuus I think I know what it is you are looking for. The Reflecting Skin is one of my favorite films. I'm guessing you are looking for something lurking in an open space instead of the obvious claustrophobic film. something intense, intelligent, unnerving and haunting. something evil that found it's way inside a serene picture. something good trying to escape an ugly place, or something ugly trying to slip into a good place. Sometimes to hide in plain sight is more frightening than dark corners we can avoid.
In short, it's about contrast.
Here are 10 films in no particular order with the same feel:
Felicia's Journey
The Pledge
Flesh and Bone
Twin Falls Idaho
Santa Sangre
Frailty
Suspiria
The Wisdom of Crocodiles
Kalifornia
The Talented Mr.Ripley

reply

Thank you all, for your recommendations!

It is interesting to see what films people come to think of when using the Reflecting Skin as a starting point. What most films (but I have not heard of all your recommendations, so I might be wrong) in common is the focus on disturbance, people in desperate situations. But this is something that can take many shapes:
The Innocents
The Pledge
Picnic at Hanging Rock
The Butcher Boy

(I saw Clark's Bully yesterday, a film that mercilessly captures how people cannot BEAR what they have done ALONE, they have to share their stories and guilt)

Ramification, you give a beautiful description of films that I look for, films that portray "something evil that found it's way inside a serene picture", as you put it.


Again: Thanks a lot!!!

reply

stuart kenny 33 is quite right about "tideland" -- i can't WAIT for this film to come out and it most certainly suggests a similar atmosphere and approach to "the reflecting skin" (if you're interested, the entertaining and moody spooky website for tideland can be found at: http://www.tidelandthemovie.com/intro.html) -- in fact, it was the very thing that made me look into "reflecting skin" again...

but i mostly wanted to respond to your query to suggest "vigil", a haunting and magical film from new zealand which i probably discovered about the same time as "reflecting skin", so i have them sort of indelibly locked together.



"But it doesn't mean anything..." a Von Trapp kid.

reply

This is a fantastic thread. It's enough to make me post my first post ever. :)

I've seen alot of the films above and agree they are similar to the "Reflecting Skin". Another movie I'd like to add to the list is "Northfork." It's extremely atmospheric, arguably as tragic, and just a tad more surrealisitc. The setting plays a HUGE role in the film. There are also various religious references, just more obvious than in "Reflecting Skin."

I haven't seen Wicker Man yet (I know, I know :p), but I've heard that's on the same level as Reflecting Skin so i can't wait to see it.

Again thanks for the thread.

- Dxfiler

reply

Dont forget Eraserhead by David Lynch. Very slow and disturbing

If you can't dazzle them with brilliance, riddle them with bullets.

reply

Io non ho paura ( I have not fear ) di Nicolò Ammaniti, absolutely similar
The Winter Guest 1997 - Alan Rickman - GB

reply

Here's one I thought was in exactly the same spirit---or treaded the same spookily disturbing ground as THE REFLECTING SKIN---a very dark 1989 comedy-drama called PARENTS---with an emphasis on the "dark" part by writer/director Bob Balaban (who played in that weird 1980 Ken Russell flick,ALTERED STATES). I'm actually surprised no one's mentioned PARENTS,considering it's also about a young boy who has some truly,dark disturbing nightmares for his age that seem to center around his parents,who are portrayed as the ideal 1950's married couple (the time period which it's set in) and how he gradually uncovered an extremely frightening secret about said parents. Worth retning out---I saw it years ago when it came out---it only played in a handful of theatres with very little promotion,none near me----and was chilled to the bone by it. It stars Randy Quaid and Mary Beth Hurt as the seemingly normal parents.

Saw THE REFLECTING SKIN on VHS some years back--I have to say it did leave a "WTF was that?" kind of impression on me,even though it's one of my least favorite films---to me it was way too dark and mean-spirited for its own good,plus it had no soul--you never really felt anything for the characters. I've always though Viggo M. was hot,ever since I saw him in G.I. JANE with Demi Moore,and it is kind of surprising that this flick hasn't been rushed out on DVD just to capitalize on his presence here,since he does have a substantial part in it. It's one-messed-up movie,though. Check out PARENTS--don't know if it's on DVD,either.

reply

possibly The Butcher Boy? A bit different but many similar undertones.

reply

the spirit is "Heavenly creatures" one. And "Eraserhead" in disturbing eye and consciousness. "Io non ho paura" more for the landscapes and atmospheres than others.

"so much going on
and I wish to hold on"

reply

When it's released later this year, TIDELAND. I've read the book and Reflecting Skin at once came to mind.

reply