The Horror Show by a pretty wide margin. Shocker never found a good balance between comedy and horror. The finale in particular was just stupid (BEAVER! BEAVER!!) The inconsistent tone kept me from ever getting really into it. On top of that, it was too long for the kind of movie it was.
Shocker also wasn't scary, at least partly because of Mitch Pileggi who wasn't intimidating or memorable enough as some bald guy with a limp. He's a TV sized star and has done strong work on The X Files, Sons of Anarchy, and Supernatural but he was out of his depth here. On the other hand, Brion James was great in The Horror Show, the perfect mix sleaze and strength, like the type of guy that would freak you out if you bumped into him at a bar or, even worse, a dark ally.
And then, obviously, Lance Henriksen alone pushes The Horror Show above Shocker, which was led by the okay but not great Peter Berg. Henriksen does a fantastic job of falling apart throughout the movie.
The Horror Show is also darker and has more startling visuals, although it seems to have been made on a smaller budget, which shows.
Neither is brilliant but The Horror Show is better. Sorry Wes.
S.F.W.
reply
share