MovieChat Forums > Tonari no Totoro (1990) Discussion > Bizarre theory: Totoro is Death?

Bizarre theory: Totoro is Death?


Okay I came across this bizarre theory about Totoro the movie, note that this is not my intepretation, just what I saw other people were discussing:

1.It is saying that Totoro is in fact messenger of Death, and whoever sees him will soon die. The hospital that the sister's mother was in was based on a real hospital for terminally-ill patients.

2. Later in the story the villagers find a slipper in a pond, which is in fact May's, at this point she has already drowned in the pond. Satsuki lied that the slipper wasn't Mei's out of denial. Ever since this scene, the sisters appeared to have no shadow.

3. Satsuki pleaded the Totoro and the cat-bus to take her to where Mei is, while on the cat-bus, says "Nobody can see us...", this scene is Satsuki leading herself to the land of the dead (by taking the cat-bus).

4. At the hospital, the mother says "I think I feel May and Satsuki smiling there in that tree..." Why don't the sisters go and see their mom if they are already there? Why do they just leave the corn there instead? It is said that the sisters were dead at that point, and the Japanese pronunciation of "corn" is similar to "kill child".

5. The final scenes seem to be a happy epilogue, but they in fact happened "before" the major events in the movie.

6. The movie was set in a place in Japan where there was a case of murdering of two sisters which happened in the 60s. This event took place on May 1st, while the sister's names are Satsuki (May in Japanese) and Mei (May in English). In the real life case, the younger sister was missing first and the older sister was seen to be looking for her frantically. Nest day, the younger sister's body was found in the forest (stabbed to death). The older sister was in such a state of shock and kept rambling ambiguous words about seeing a "cat monster", "great big racoon monster" etc to the police. The sisters were in fact from a single-parent family (mother died of illness).

Ever since these rumors started to circulate, people have been calling Ghibli for verification "is Totoro Death" "Why don't the sisters have shadows later in the movie", and Ghibli made announcment on their blog site about the shadow issue saying that there was no shadow because the animators decided there was no shadow needed in those scenes (maybe bc of light source etc).

Here is Ghibli's blog site with the responses (anyone knows Japanese, can you verify?): http://www.ghibli.jp/15diary/003717.html

---

I personally was a bit shocked to learn of this theory, kind of skeptical really, because the details of the "real-life" murder event are really sketchy, and how the older sister died was not said. It's just hard to verify. And 5. the issue with the epilogue being prologue, wasn't there a baby brother at the end?...How can that be before the story...

So what do you think...Too much BS? Or eerie coincidence?



Let nobody tell you what to do, gotta be the judge and the jury, too!

reply

WOW way to turn this wonderful movie that actually made me very happy into something that makes me depressed. Really thank you alot!

reply

[deleted]

Sounds like a load of *beep* to me... i looked up the #4 thing all over online and found nothing leading to anything remotely near that.


ill say as well

If totoro is death

how and why does he create trees? Possibly the most symbolic concept of life

reply

[deleted]

They do have shadows after the shoe was found. On the cat bus they have shadows behing them, then when they get off they have slight shadows although it is almost dark so they can't really have much of a shadow anyway.
The reason they didn't go into the hospital was because they didn't want to get caught there. They weren't supposed top be there so just left the sweetcorn there and left, instead of going in and getting caught.

reply

Oh Internet, why must you be so full of information I would have rather never heard...

_____

Thank you movie-scientists, for explaining me why I shouldn't enjoy this movie.

reply

I appreciate you ruining a movie I have enjoyed since I was a young pup.

"You clumsy silverback watch my *beep* legs!"

reply

One thing missing from this theory: the film doesn't end at the hospital. In the end, the cat bus takes the girls back near their home, where they meat the old grandma and Kanta. They hug, talk and start walking back home.

As for the shadows, the grandma and Kanta don't have shadows in the end scene either, but it's quite improbable to think that it would mean that they would have somehow died too. And if they are alive, then the girls have to be too. Besides, there are a few scenes earlier in the movie where people don't have shadows either.

All in all, I'd say it's a coincidence. One of those cases when you look hard enough, you'll find something, relevant or not.

reply

I just watched it again, the sisters do in fact have shadows at the end. It's just not as obvious because it's night. And the story about the murders of the two sisters is made up, never happened.

reply

I hate you, I love this movie so much because it is the only movie that has no depressing aspects at all and you screwed that up in 10 or so lines :(

I love lamp...... and that is a scientific fact!

I also <3 Jessica Alba

reply

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sayama_Incident

Sayama Incident-- no mention of the sister finding the body, or anything about a raccoon...

reply