John Lithgow is Terrifying!
I grew up in Payson, UT where the majority of this movie was filmed and John Lithgow scared the hell out of me. I was young and couldn't separate fiction from reality, so I thought he was a real guy who lived in my town. After I grew up a little and realized he was an actor, I was still crapping my pants when I would see him in something. (Um, "Cliffhanger"? yeah...) It wasn't until I started watching "3rd Rock From The Sun" that I finally calmed down and decided that he wasn't really a psycho preacher that I might run into while grocery shopping.
Why would anyone want to kill the cook? Dinner wasn't that bad.