MovieChat Forums > A Christmas Story (1983) Discussion > Did Schwartz's mother really abuse him?

Did Schwartz's mother really abuse him?


Because the next day he seemed like he was able to carry on like nothing happened and didn't appear to be scarred for life from the beating he received from his mother.

reply

Back then we called beatings like that, “Wednesday”.

reply

I grew up in the 90's and my mother would explain to me what happened and then use the paddle on me.

reply

My dad did the same except he used jumper cables.

reply

Lol, awesome answer!

reply


Back when I was a kid, most of us got whaled but good when we misbehaved, and we went to school the next day having long forgotten about it. We were a different and tougher breed.

The "soap blindness" scene really hits home with us older folks because in addition to any deserved punishment, we often got whacked for things that weren't our fault. Having a fantasy about an undeserved punishment causing our parents anguish is right on.

reply

In that case Ralphie did drop the F bomb, so he wasn't really innocent. It did seem pretty harsh, though.

reply


True, but the way Ralphie was describing the relative merits of various soaps (he kind of liked Palmolive), it sounded like getting soap dosed was fairly routine which would kind of suggest (based on percentages) that somewhere along the line he got a mouthful of soap for something that didn't merit being soaped or something that he didn't actually do.

reply

Children are only scarred for life when you don't beat them.

reply

She didn't abuse him.

reply

What did she do to him? The way she was screaming made me believe she was abusing him.

reply

It's called spanking you snowflake

reply

Belts, paddles, coat hangers, hair brushes, switches off trees, and bare hands--back when I was a kid there was no end to the creativity my dad brought to corporal punishment. Abuse? Naw, just another day in the life of a 1950s-1960s kid. The wooden coat hangers were my favorite, because they'd always break after a few whacks and he'd stop.

Also, taste-sampled my share of soap bars. That was my mom's specialty. Didn't work, though--I cuss worse than a sailor.

reply

Also, taste-sampled my share of soap bars. That was my mom's specialty. Didn't work, though--I cuss worse than a sailor.


I'm sure my sons swear like a sailor, or worse, like you, but they don't swear in front of my wife or I, and we returned the favor. I know of one incident where my younger son got a taste of soap from my wife but it might have been more from mouthing off.

I'm sure all parents know their kids swear even if they don't hear it.

reply

My mom rarely heard it from me, and only if I cut loose and didn't know she was within range. Today, I never cuss in front of kids, old ladies, preachers, or anybody else I sense might not appreciate it. But at other times...

reply

seemed more like a massage.

reply

In my day, use of improper language (and not just swearing) led to being chased around the house and having one's mouth washed out with soap (yuck!).

reply

It would be funny if the sequel had him permanently disabled as an adult from that beating.
And he was on quest to find out who told on him.

reply

It's really sad kids today aren't nearly as resillient as they were back in the old days.

reply