MovieChat Forums > Pink Floyd: The Wall (1982) Discussion > Rank Your Top Ten Pink FLoyd Songs

Rank Your Top Ten Pink FLoyd Songs


1)Echoes
2)Time
3)Comfortably Numb
4)Brain Damage/Eclipse
5)Us And Them
6)Sheep
7)The Great Gig In The Sky
8)Shine On YOu Crazy Diamond
9)Breathe
10)Dogs

"This MAn Is no Theif,Serial Killer and Liar!!! He IS A God..."

reply

Time
Sheep
Echoes
Welcome to the Machine
Comfortably Numb
Fearless
SOYCD
High Hopes
Cirrus Minor
Another Brick 2

reply

[deleted]

1. High Hopes
2. Coming Back to life
3. Time
4. Comfortably Numb
5. Learning to Fly
6. Us and Them
7. Wish you were here
8. Shine on you crazy diamond
9. Lost for words
10. Sorrow

But not necessarily in the order I mentioned :-)..Absolutely love Pink Floyd

reply

I can't do it, I can't narrow it down. I've tried, I keep going back and changing it before I actually post it. I can't do it. They are pretty much all my favorites- up until waters left the band. After that I have mixed feelings on pink floyd. I don't have a problem with gilmour, I just like him better when waters was there too. I think they were awesome together. I didn't like it when they parted ways.there are some songs I didn't see anyone else mention in their posts- 2 come to mind that I think should be on there.
One of these days-
Pigs (three different ones)-

Richard wright- R.I.P.

Oops! Those songs are listed, sorry about that.

reply

1. Astronomy Domonie
2. Lucifer Sam
3. Matilda Mother
4. Flaming
5. Chapter 24
6. The Gnome
7. Bike
8. Vegetable Man
9. Scream Thy Last Scream (Old woman with a casket)
10.See Emily Play

R.I.P. Syd & Rick



reply

Off the top of my head... in no particular order (I know the subject says "Rank")

Interstellar Overdrive
Set The Controls To The Heart Of The Sun
The Great Gig In The Sky
Money
The Trial
I'm tempted to say Echoes
When The Tigers Broke Free
Sheep
Any Colour You Like
A Saucerful Of Secrets


__________________
I've come to warn you! In three million years, you'll be dead!

reply

Maybe I'll be labeled as not a true Pink Floyd fan and the music is different but the stuff they did after Roger Waters left I think is some of their best. I think it was fitting that after Waters mouthed off that Pink Floyd was finished, with him leaving, that that was when they won their only Grammy. However, you don't have to like the man to like their music and with that being said, In No Order:

1. Comfortably Numb
2. Time
3. Us and Them
4. Wish You Were Here
5. Hey You
6. Goodbye Blue Sky
7. Lost For Words
8. High Hopes
9. Learning to Fly
10. On the Turning Away

reply

Nah, no one will label you that, and who cares if they do? Who's to say what it takes to be a "true pink floyd fan" we are all true fans.

reply

[deleted]

"you cant name best songs, their albums are like long songs"

With the exception of Dark Side of the Moon I can't agree that their albums are like long songs. But because I have agreed on thinking Dark Side of the Moon counts as one song there's goes all ten of mine. =(

reply

1. The great gig in the sky
2. Echoes
3. One of these days
4. Breathe
5. Brain damage/eclipse
6. Shine on you crazy diamond
7. Time
8. Nile song
9. The fletcher memorial home
10. Money

reply

1 shine on you crazy diamond
2 wish you were here
3 on the turning away
4 coming back to life
5 the great gig in the sky
6 brain damage/eclipse
7 time
8 another brick in the wall part 3
9 poles apart
10 bike.

RIP Syd and Rick

reply

In no real order:

1.Shine On You Crazy Diamond
2.Echoes
3.Time
4.Atom Heart Mother
5.Us and Them
6.Comfortably Numb
7.Another Brick in the Wall Part 2
8.The Fletcher Memorial Home
9.A Great Day for Freedom
10.Lost for Words

Bill Foster: I'm the bad guy?...How did that happen?

reply

In no order:

Comfortably Numb
Sheep
Dogs
Hey You
Mother
Shine on you crazy diamond
Brain Damage - Eclipse
Us and Them
Learning to Fly
Wish You Were Here

It would have been easier to do a top 30.

reply

[deleted]

1.Another Brick In The Wall Pt.2
2.Money
3.Brain Damage/Eclipse
4.Another Brick In The Wall Pt.1
5.The Happiest Days Of Our Lives
6.The Trial
7.Comfortably Numb
8.The Dogs Of War
9.Another Brick In The Wall Pt.3
10.Time

reply

1) Time
2) Another Brick in the Wall, part II
3) Shine on You Crazy Diamond
4) Speak to me/Breathe
5) Young Lust
6) Learning to Fly
7) Wish You Were Here
8) Have a Cigar
9) Comfortably Numb
10) Brain Damage

reply

This is hard...

Erm...

Oh, nice to see some people made references to Meddle, one of my faves.

1. SOYCD parts 1 & 2
2. Brain damage
3. Wish you were here
4. One of these days
5. San tropez (listening to it right now hehe)
6. In the flesh?
7. Comfortably numb
8. Great gig in the sky
9. Money
10. The trial

I think that's my conclusive decision, i spent alot of time on that list.


* Are You Gunna Bark All Day Lil Doggy, Or You Gunna Bite? *

reply

1: The Great Gig in the Sky (My Father, wanting to introduce me to Pink Floyd, showed me this song, and just played it and i instantly understood why they are just amazing)
2: Echoes
3: Marooned
4: Comfortably Numb
5: Time
6: Pigs (Three Different Ones)
7: Nobody Home
8: Wish You Were Here
9: Money
10: The Trial

---------------------------------------
who ate all the crunchy cream pies?

reply