MovieChat Forums > Dressed to Kill (1980) Discussion > Classic example of censorship making thi...

Classic example of censorship making things worse *MAJOR SPOILERS*


As staunch fans of the film know, the US 'R' rated version - which was apparently sold internationally - considerably dilutes Kate's elevator murder.

In the uncut version, the 'coup de grace' is shown. As the climax to some generally more explicit slashing and dicing, 'Bobby' finally slashes Kate's neck arteries, which will obviously result in a fairly swift demise no matter how quickly the medics could arrive on the scene.

In its truncated form however, this particular shot is eliminated along with several others; as a result of which, the supposedly 'toned down' sequence just comes across as a bit of showy slashing with a bucket of blood having been sloppily sloshed around.

For me, all that achieves is to remove that realistic edge of 'painful' murder from what has ensued. Since we don't see the actual injury that makes Kate plausbily die, it feels like a more 'superficially enjoyable' screen spectacle because it is a bit bloody; rather than being a gruelling, harrowing sequence depicting the prolonged actuality involved in getting a human body to die - which is far more soberingly horrific.



reply

Correct, although with the censors doing this, it actually brings this film more into line as a Psycho tribute, because it was the principle of not actually showing the death blows that Hitchcock used to make the shower scene more disturbing.

reply

It's not that badly edited though.

reply

Board,
I have the unrated film version on DVD. I dont care what anyone else says, the murder scene in the elevator is so horrifically graphic, on the unrated version, that I am spooked to the point of paranoia, about entering and exiting elevators. That scene of violence is so vicious, and cold blooded. It just maakes me think about all of the real weirdo's, in real life, that are engaging in such acticity, somewhere in this world. What a truly horroriffic scene of terror!!! Thanks, Brian for my wonderful nightmares, I will be suffering from with the aftereffects of this film.


Anthony Cashmere
It isn't fair, using the living, to bring back the dead!!!-THE SCREAMING SKULL

reply

I have never seen the X-rated version of Dressed to Kill, but have read it is much more graphic just the R-rated version and the commercial TV prints. I agree what some have said that the R-rated version gives the film more of "Hitchcock" "Psycho" effect concerning the murders where everything is not spelled out for the viewer. For this reason, I think the R-rated version is better.

Joe

reply

X-rated/unrated elevator scene: http://youtu.be/R8_HfT2ndyg.

X-rated/unrated dream sequence: http://youtu.be/GiNKTYoCWG4.

reply

It's not censorship ,but allowing the film to receive an R rating. Of course it had to toned down. They didn't have to, but chose to.

reply

They were obligated to get an R-rating, so yeah, it's censorship.

reply

I hate this abused housewife excuse, ‘I chose to get a beating because I didn’t obey his rules, it’s my fault’.

The MPAA decides what is acceptable to them and what isn’t (and will be financially punished for it), they are censors.

reply

To me, the unrated version of this scene is just over the top. I prefer the restraint of the R-rated version; it's gruesome enough. The indulgence of the unrated version takes me out of the story. It lacks artistry.

reply

To me, the unrated version of this scene is just over the top. I prefer the restraint of the R-rated version; it's gruesome enough. The indulgence of the unrated version takes me out of the story. It lacks artistry.


Yes, I agree.

reply

Lacks artistry?!?! You gotta be joking. Just because you're a squeamish sissy doesn't mean this version lacks artistry. Get real.

reply